Theory of Computing Report

Authors: Robert Andrews, Abhibhav Garg

We study the question of explicitly constructing variety-evasive subspace families, a pseudorandom primitive introduced by Guo (Computational Complexity 2024) that generalizes both hitting sets and lossless rank condensers. Roughly speaking, a variety-evasive subspace family $\mathcal{H}$ is a collection of subspaces such that for every algebraic variety $V$ in a fixed family $\mathcal{F}$, there is some subspace $W \in \mathcal{H}$ that is in general position with respect to $V$. We give an explicit construction of a subspace families that evade all degree-$d$ varieties in an $n$-dimensional affine or projective space. Our construction improves on the size of the variety-evasive subspace families constructed by Guo and, for varieties of degree $n^{1 + Ω(1)}$, comes within a polynomial factor of Guo's lower bound on the size of any such variety-evasive subspace family. Our variety-evasive subspace families rely on an improved construction of hitting sets for Chow forms of algebraic varieties.

Authors: Robert Andrews, Abhibhav Garg

We study the question of explicitly constructing variety-evasive subspace families, a pseudorandom primitive introduced by Guo (Computational Complexity 2024) that generalizes both hitting sets and lossless rank condensers. Roughly speaking, a variety-evasive subspace family $\mathcal{H}$ is a collection of subspaces such that for every algebraic variety $V$ in a fixed family $\mathcal{F}$, there is some subspace $W \in \mathcal{H}$ that is in general position with respect to $V$. We give an explicit construction of a subspace families that evade all degree-$d$ varieties in an $n$-dimensional affine or projective space. Our construction improves on the size of the variety-evasive subspace families constructed by Guo and, for varieties of degree $n^{1 + Ω(1)}$, comes within a polynomial factor of Guo's lower bound on the size of any such variety-evasive subspace family. Our variety-evasive subspace families rely on an improved construction of hitting sets for Chow forms of algebraic varieties.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

Partial Evidence Bench: Benchmarking Authorization-Limited Evidence in Agentic Systems

Authors: Krti Tallam

Enterprise agents increasingly operate inside scoped retrieval systems, delegated workflows, and policy-constrained evidence environments. In these settings, access control can be enforced correctly while the system still produces an answer that appears complete even though material evidence lies outside the caller's authorization boundary. This paper introduces Partial Evidence Bench, a deterministic benchmark for measuring that failure mode. The benchmark ships three scenario families -- due diligence, compliance audit, and security incident response -- with 72 tasks total, ACL-partitioned corpora, oracle complete answers, oracle authorized-view answers, oracle completeness judgments, and structured gap-report oracles. It evaluates systems along four surfaces: answer correctness, completeness awareness, gap-report quality, and unsafe completeness behavior. Checked-in baselines show that silent filtering is catastrophically unsafe across all shipped families, while explicit fail-and-report behavior eliminates unsafe completeness without collapsing the task into trivial abstention. Preliminary real-model runs show model-dependent and scenario-sensitive differences in whether systems overclaim completeness, conservatively underclaim, or report incompleteness in an enterprise-usable form. The benchmark's broader contribution is to make a governance-critical agent failure measurable without human judges or contamination-prone static corpora.

Authors: Krti Tallam

Enterprise agents increasingly operate inside scoped retrieval systems, delegated workflows, and policy-constrained evidence environments. In these settings, access control can be enforced correctly while the system still produces an answer that appears complete even though material evidence lies outside the caller's authorization boundary. This paper introduces Partial Evidence Bench, a deterministic benchmark for measuring that failure mode. The benchmark ships three scenario families -- due diligence, compliance audit, and security incident response -- with 72 tasks total, ACL-partitioned corpora, oracle complete answers, oracle authorized-view answers, oracle completeness judgments, and structured gap-report oracles. It evaluates systems along four surfaces: answer correctness, completeness awareness, gap-report quality, and unsafe completeness behavior. Checked-in baselines show that silent filtering is catastrophically unsafe across all shipped families, while explicit fail-and-report behavior eliminates unsafe completeness without collapsing the task into trivial abstention. Preliminary real-model runs show model-dependent and scenario-sensitive differences in whether systems overclaim completeness, conservatively underclaim, or report incompleteness in an enterprise-usable form. The benchmark's broader contribution is to make a governance-critical agent failure measurable without human judges or contamination-prone static corpora.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

Scalable GPU Construction of 3D Voronoi and Power Diagrams

Authors: Bernardo Taveira, Carl Lindström, Maryam Fatemi, Lars Hammarstrand, Fredrik Kahl

Voronoi diagrams, and their more general weighted counterpart, power diagrams, are fundamental geometric constructs with wide-ranging applications. Recently, they have gained renewed attention in mesh-based neural rendering. Despite being extensively studied, the construction of 3D Voronoi diagrams for large-scale point sets remains computationally expensive, limiting their adoption in large-scale applications. Existing CPU-based approaches typically rely on computing its dual, the Delaunay tetrahedralization, but are prohibitively slow for large diagrams, while GPU-based methods either struggle to scale efficiently to large point sets or assume homogeneous point distributions. The weighted case, power diagrams, is even less explored in this context. Existing approaches are typically tailored to the application at hand, assuming homogeneous point distributions and small weight variations, making them unsuitable for general use in more complex heterogeneous data. In this paper, we present a highly parallelizable GPU algorithm for the fast construction of large-scale 3D Voronoi and power diagrams. Our approach constructs each convex cell from a weighted 3D point by progressively clipping an initial cell volume against bisecting planes induced by candidate neighboring points. To efficiently identify candidate neighbors under arbitrary spatial distributions, we introduce a culling criterion based on directional geometric bounds of the evolving cell, combined with a hierarchical best-first traversal of bounding volumes. We achieve performance on par with state-of-the-art Delaunay tetrahedralization methods on small and moderate problem sizes, while exhibiting robust scalability to large point sets and diverse spatial distributions. Moreover, our method naturally generalizes to power diagrams without additional assumptions. See research.zenseact.com/publications/paragram .

Authors: Bernardo Taveira, Carl Lindström, Maryam Fatemi, Lars Hammarstrand, Fredrik Kahl

Voronoi diagrams, and their more general weighted counterpart, power diagrams, are fundamental geometric constructs with wide-ranging applications. Recently, they have gained renewed attention in mesh-based neural rendering. Despite being extensively studied, the construction of 3D Voronoi diagrams for large-scale point sets remains computationally expensive, limiting their adoption in large-scale applications. Existing CPU-based approaches typically rely on computing its dual, the Delaunay tetrahedralization, but are prohibitively slow for large diagrams, while GPU-based methods either struggle to scale efficiently to large point sets or assume homogeneous point distributions. The weighted case, power diagrams, is even less explored in this context. Existing approaches are typically tailored to the application at hand, assuming homogeneous point distributions and small weight variations, making them unsuitable for general use in more complex heterogeneous data. In this paper, we present a highly parallelizable GPU algorithm for the fast construction of large-scale 3D Voronoi and power diagrams. Our approach constructs each convex cell from a weighted 3D point by progressively clipping an initial cell volume against bisecting planes induced by candidate neighboring points. To efficiently identify candidate neighbors under arbitrary spatial distributions, we introduce a culling criterion based on directional geometric bounds of the evolving cell, combined with a hierarchical best-first traversal of bounding volumes. We achieve performance on par with state-of-the-art Delaunay tetrahedralization methods on small and moderate problem sizes, while exhibiting robust scalability to large point sets and diverse spatial distributions. Moreover, our method naturally generalizes to power diagrams without additional assumptions. See https://research.zenseact.com/publications/paragram .

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

Geometry-Aware Simplicial Message Passing

Authors: Elena Xinyi Wang, Bastian Rieck

The Weisfeiler--Lehman (WL) test and its simplicial extension (SWL) characterize the combinatorial expressivity of message passing networks, but they are blind to geometry, i.e., meshes with identical connectivity but different embeddings are indistinguishable. We introduce the Geometric Simplicial Weisfeiler--Lehman (GSWL) test, which incorporates vertex coordinates into color refinement for geometric simplicial complexes. In addition, we show that (i) the expressivity of geometry-aware simplicial message passing schemes is bounded above by GSWL, and (ii) that there exist parameters such that the discriminating power of GSWL is matched by these schemes on any fixed finite family of geometric simplicial complexes. Combined with the Euler Characteristic Transform (ECT), a complete invariant for geometric simplicial complexes, this yields a geometric expressivity characterization together with an approximation framework. Experiments on synthetic and mesh datasets serve to validate our theory, showing a clear hierarchy from combinatorial to geometry-aware models.

Authors: Elena Xinyi Wang, Bastian Rieck

The Weisfeiler--Lehman (WL) test and its simplicial extension (SWL) characterize the combinatorial expressivity of message passing networks, but they are blind to geometry, i.e., meshes with identical connectivity but different embeddings are indistinguishable. We introduce the Geometric Simplicial Weisfeiler--Lehman (GSWL) test, which incorporates vertex coordinates into color refinement for geometric simplicial complexes. In addition, we show that (i) the expressivity of geometry-aware simplicial message passing schemes is bounded above by GSWL, and (ii) that there exist parameters such that the discriminating power of GSWL is matched by these schemes on any fixed finite family of geometric simplicial complexes. Combined with the Euler Characteristic Transform (ECT), a complete invariant for geometric simplicial complexes, this yields a geometric expressivity characterization together with an approximation framework. Experiments on synthetic and mesh datasets serve to validate our theory, showing a clear hierarchy from combinatorial to geometry-aware models.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

A Constant-Factor Approximation for Continuous Dynamic Time Warping in 2D

Authors: Kevin Buchin, Maike Buchin, Jan Erik Swiadek, Sampson Wong

Continuous Dynamic Time Warping (CDTW) is a robust similarity measure for polygonal curves that has recently found a variety of applications. Despite its practical use, not much is known about the algorithmic complexity of computing it in 2D, especially when one requires either an exact solution or strong approximation guarantees. We fill this gap by introducing a $5$-approximation algorithm with running time $O(n^5)$ under the 1-norm. This is the first constant-factor approximation for 2D CDTW with polynomial running time. We extend our algorithm to all polygonal norms on $\mathbb{R}^2$, which we subsequently use in order to achieve a $(5+\varepsilon)$-approximation with time complexity $O(n^5 / \varepsilon^{1/2})$ for CDTW in 2D under any fixed norm. The latter result in particular includes the usual Euclidean 2-norm.

Authors: Kevin Buchin, Maike Buchin, Jan Erik Swiadek, Sampson Wong

Continuous Dynamic Time Warping (CDTW) is a robust similarity measure for polygonal curves that has recently found a variety of applications. Despite its practical use, not much is known about the algorithmic complexity of computing it in 2D, especially when one requires either an exact solution or strong approximation guarantees. We fill this gap by introducing a $5$-approximation algorithm with running time $O(n^5)$ under the 1-norm. This is the first constant-factor approximation for 2D CDTW with polynomial running time. We extend our algorithm to all polygonal norms on $\mathbb{R}^2$, which we subsequently use in order to achieve a $(5+\varepsilon)$-approximation with time complexity $O(n^5 / \varepsilon^{1/2})$ for CDTW in 2D under any fixed norm. The latter result in particular includes the usual Euclidean 2-norm.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

Planar morphometry via functional shape data analysis and quasi-conformal mappings

Authors: Hangyu Li, Gary P. T. Choi

The study of shapes is one of the most fundamental problems in life sciences. Although numerous methods have been developed for the morphometry of planar biological shapes over the past several decades, most of them focus solely on either the outer silhouettes or the interior features of the shapes without capturing the coupling between them. Moreover, many existing shape mapping techniques are limited to establishing correspondence between planar structures without further allowing for the quantitative analysis or modelling of shape changes. In this work, we introduce FDA-QC, a novel planar morphometry method that combines functional shape data analysis (FDA) techniques and quasi-conformal (QC) mappings, taking both the boundary and interior of the planar shapes into consideration. Specifically, closed planar curves are represented by their square-root velocity functions and registered by elastic matching in the function space. The induced boundary correspondence is then extended to the entire planar domains by a quasi-conformal map, optionally with landmark constraints. Moreover, the proposed FDA-QC method can naturally lead to a unified framework for shape morphing and shape variation quantification. We apply the FDA-QC method to various leaf and insect wing datasets, and the experimental results show that the proposed combined approach captures morphological variation more effectively than purely boundary-based or interior-based descriptions. Altogether, our work paves a new way for understanding the growth and form of planar biological shapes.

Authors: Hangyu Li, Gary P. T. Choi

The study of shapes is one of the most fundamental problems in life sciences. Although numerous methods have been developed for the morphometry of planar biological shapes over the past several decades, most of them focus solely on either the outer silhouettes or the interior features of the shapes without capturing the coupling between them. Moreover, many existing shape mapping techniques are limited to establishing correspondence between planar structures without further allowing for the quantitative analysis or modelling of shape changes. In this work, we introduce FDA-QC, a novel planar morphometry method that combines functional shape data analysis (FDA) techniques and quasi-conformal (QC) mappings, taking both the boundary and interior of the planar shapes into consideration. Specifically, closed planar curves are represented by their square-root velocity functions and registered by elastic matching in the function space. The induced boundary correspondence is then extended to the entire planar domains by a quasi-conformal map, optionally with landmark constraints. Moreover, the proposed FDA-QC method can naturally lead to a unified framework for shape morphing and shape variation quantification. We apply the FDA-QC method to various leaf and insect wing datasets, and the experimental results show that the proposed combined approach captures morphological variation more effectively than purely boundary-based or interior-based descriptions. Altogether, our work paves a new way for understanding the growth and form of planar biological shapes.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

Bilateral Treewidth for QBF: Where Strategies and Resolution Meet

Authors: Robert Ganian, Marlene Gründel

Treewidth is a well-studied decompositional parameter to measure the tree-likeness of a graph. While the propositional satisfiability problem (SAT) is known to be tractable when parameterized by the treewidth of the underlying primal graph, the evaluation of quantified Boolean formulas (QBFs) remains PSPACE-complete even on formulas of constant treewidth. Intuitively, this is because ordinary treewidth does not take into account the prefix of the QBF: it neither distinguishes between existential and universal variables, nor accounts for the order in which they are quantified. In the past, several weaker variants of treewidth have been devised to incorporate prefix-sensitive information. To establish tractability for QBFs under these notions, prior work has employed either strategy- or resolution-based techniques, thereby dividing the parameterized complexity landscape of QBF into two regimes that are incomparable in strength. We establish fixed-parameter tractability with respect to bilateral treewidth, a novel and strictly more powerful decompositional parameter that combines these rivaling approaches by simultaneously allowing for branching on strategies and performing Q-resolution. As in previous works in this direction, our algorithm assumes that a suitable tree decomposition is provided on the input.

Authors: Robert Ganian, Marlene Gründel

Treewidth is a well-studied decompositional parameter to measure the tree-likeness of a graph. While the propositional satisfiability problem (SAT) is known to be tractable when parameterized by the treewidth of the underlying primal graph, the evaluation of quantified Boolean formulas (QBFs) remains PSPACE-complete even on formulas of constant treewidth. Intuitively, this is because ordinary treewidth does not take into account the prefix of the QBF: it neither distinguishes between existential and universal variables, nor accounts for the order in which they are quantified. In the past, several weaker variants of treewidth have been devised to incorporate prefix-sensitive information. To establish tractability for QBFs under these notions, prior work has employed either strategy- or resolution-based techniques, thereby dividing the parameterized complexity landscape of QBF into two regimes that are incomparable in strength. We establish fixed-parameter tractability with respect to bilateral treewidth, a novel and strictly more powerful decompositional parameter that combines these rivaling approaches by simultaneously allowing for branching on strategies and performing Q-resolution. As in previous works in this direction, our algorithm assumes that a suitable tree decomposition is provided on the input.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

Algorithmic Phase Transition for Large Independent Sets in Dense Hypergraphs

Authors: Abhishek Dhawan, Nhi U. Dinh, Eren C. Kızıldağ, Neeladri Maitra, Bayram A. Şahin

We study the algorithmic tractability of finding large independent sets in dense random hypergraphs. In the sparse regime, much of the natural algorithms can be formulated within either the local or the low-degree polynomial (LDP) framework, and a rich literature has subsequently identified nearly sharp algorithmic thresholds within these classes by exploiting their stability. In the dense setting, however, the algorithmic paradigms are fundamentally different: they are online and thus need not be stable. Perhaps more crucially, even for the classical Erdős-Rényi random graph $G(n,p)$, LDPs are conjectured to fail in the 'easy' regime accessible to online algorithms, thereby challenging their viability for dense models. Our focus is on two models: (i) finding large independent sets in dense $r$-uniform Erdős-Rényi hypergraphs, and (ii) the more challenging problem of finding large $γ$-balanced independent sets in dense $r$-uniform $r$-partite hypergraphs, where the $i$-th coordinate of $γ\in\mathbb{Q}^r$ specifies the proportion of vertices from $V_i$ in the independent set. For both models, we pinpoint the size of the largest independent set and design online algorithms that achieve a multiplicative approximation factor of $r^{1/(r-1)}$ in the uniform and $(\max_i γ_i)^{-1/(r-1)}$ in the $r$-partite model. Furthermore, we establish matching algorithmic lower bounds, showing that these computational gaps are sharp: no online algorithms can breach these gaps.

Authors: Abhishek Dhawan, Nhi U. Dinh, Eren C. Kızıldağ, Neeladri Maitra, Bayram A. Şahin

We study the algorithmic tractability of finding large independent sets in dense random hypergraphs. In the sparse regime, much of the natural algorithms can be formulated within either the local or the low-degree polynomial (LDP) framework, and a rich literature has subsequently identified nearly sharp algorithmic thresholds within these classes by exploiting their stability. In the dense setting, however, the algorithmic paradigms are fundamentally different: they are online and thus need not be stable. Perhaps more crucially, even for the classical Erdős-Rényi random graph $G(n,p)$, LDPs are conjectured to fail in the 'easy' regime accessible to online algorithms, thereby challenging their viability for dense models. Our focus is on two models: (i) finding large independent sets in dense $r$-uniform Erdős-Rényi hypergraphs, and (ii) the more challenging problem of finding large $γ$-balanced independent sets in dense $r$-uniform $r$-partite hypergraphs, where the $i$-th coordinate of $γ\in\mathbb{Q}^r$ specifies the proportion of vertices from $V_i$ in the independent set. For both models, we pinpoint the size of the largest independent set and design online algorithms that achieve a multiplicative approximation factor of $r^{1/(r-1)}$ in the uniform and $(\max_i γ_i)^{-1/(r-1)}$ in the $r$-partite model. Furthermore, we establish matching algorithmic lower bounds, showing that these computational gaps are sharp: no online algorithms can breach these gaps.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

Fast decremental tree sums in forests

Authors: Benjamin Aram Berendsohn, Marek Sokołowski

We study two fundamental decremental dynamic graph problems. In both problems, we need to maintain a vertex-weighted forest of size $n$ under edge deletions, weight updates, and a certain information-retrieval query. Both problems can be solved in $O(\log n)$ time per update/query using standard dynamic forest data structures like top trees, even if additionally edge insertions are allowed. We investigate whether the deletion-only problem can be solved faster. First, we consider $\texttt{tree-sum}$ queries, where we ask for the sum of vertex weights in one of the connected components (i.e., trees) in the forest. We give a data structure with $O(n)$ preprocessing time and $O(\log^* n)$ time per operation, based on a micro-macro tree decomposition (Alstrup et al., 1997). If the forest is unweighted (i.e., all weights are 1 and cannot be changed), then the operation time can be improved to $O(1)$. Additionally, we give an asymptotically universally optimal algorithm. More specifically, our algorithm works in the group model, and processes $m$ operations on an initial forest $F$ in running time $O( \mathrm{OPT}(F, m) )$. Here $\mathrm{OPT}(F, m)$ is the number of weight additions and subtractions that a best possible algorithm performs to handle a worst-case instance for a fixed initial forest $F$ and a fixed number $m$ of operations. We achieve this with a combination of the aforementioned decomposition technique, precomputation of optimal data structures for very small instances, and some insights into the behavior of $\mathrm{OPT}$. Note that even the worst-case complexity of this algorithm remains unknown to us. Second, we consider $\texttt{subtree-sum}$ queries. Here, the forest is rooted, and a query $\texttt{subtree-sum}(v)$ returns the sum of weights in the subtree rooted at $v$. We show tight bounds for several variants of this problem. [...]

Authors: Benjamin Aram Berendsohn, Marek Sokołowski

We study two fundamental decremental dynamic graph problems. In both problems, we need to maintain a vertex-weighted forest of size $n$ under edge deletions, weight updates, and a certain information-retrieval query. Both problems can be solved in $O(\log n)$ time per update/query using standard dynamic forest data structures like top trees, even if additionally edge insertions are allowed. We investigate whether the deletion-only problem can be solved faster. First, we consider $\texttt{tree-sum}$ queries, where we ask for the sum of vertex weights in one of the connected components (i.e., trees) in the forest. We give a data structure with $O(n)$ preprocessing time and $O(\log^* n)$ time per operation, based on a micro-macro tree decomposition (Alstrup et al., 1997). If the forest is unweighted (i.e., all weights are 1 and cannot be changed), then the operation time can be improved to $O(1)$. Additionally, we give an asymptotically universally optimal algorithm. More specifically, our algorithm works in the group model, and processes $m$ operations on an initial forest $F$ in running time $O( \mathrm{OPT}(F, m) )$. Here $\mathrm{OPT}(F, m)$ is the number of weight additions and subtractions that a best possible algorithm performs to handle a worst-case instance for a fixed initial forest $F$ and a fixed number $m$ of operations. We achieve this with a combination of the aforementioned decomposition technique, precomputation of optimal data structures for very small instances, and some insights into the behavior of $\mathrm{OPT}$. Note that even the worst-case complexity of this algorithm remains unknown to us. Second, we consider $\texttt{subtree-sum}$ queries. Here, the forest is rooted, and a query $\texttt{subtree-sum}(v)$ returns the sum of weights in the subtree rooted at $v$. We show tight bounds for several variants of this problem. [...]

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

On the Parameterized Approximability of (Mergeable) Sum of Radii Clustering

Authors: Ameet Gadekar

The sum of radii problem ($k$-MSR) asks, given a metric space on $n$ points, to place $k$ balls covering all points so as to minimize the sum of their radii. Despite extensive study from the perspectives of approximation and parameterized algorithms, the exact parameterized complexity of the problem and the existence of efficient parameterized approximation schemes remained open. We advance this understanding on both the hardness and algorithmic fronts. We begin by showing that $k$-MSR is $W[2]$-hard parameterized by $k$, thereby pinpointing its location in the $W$-hierarchy. Moreover, via our reduction, we rule out efficient parameterized approximation schemes (EPAS)--that is, $(1+ε)$-approximations running in time $f(k,ε)\cdot \mathrm{poly}(n)$--unless $W[2] = FPT$. Assuming the Exponential Time Hypothesis, we further rule out such algorithms running in time $f(k,ε)\cdot n^{o(k)}$, strengthening recent lower bounds for the problem. On the algorithmic side, we study $k$-MSR under the framework of mergeable constraints, which captures a broad class of clustering constraints, including fairness, diversity, and lower bounds. We obtain an FPT $(\frac{8}{3}+ε)$-approximation, improving upon the previous best guarantee of $(4+ε)$. Moreover, given access to a suitable assignment subroutine, we achieve a $(2+ε)$-approximation, matching the best known bound for the unconstrained problem. This, in turn, yields $(2+ε)$ FPT-approximations for several important settings, including $(t,k)$-fair, $(α,β)$-fair, $\ell$-diversity, and private clustering.

Authors: Ameet Gadekar

The sum of radii problem ($k$-MSR) asks, given a metric space on $n$ points, to place $k$ balls covering all points so as to minimize the sum of their radii. Despite extensive study from the perspectives of approximation and parameterized algorithms, the exact parameterized complexity of the problem and the existence of efficient parameterized approximation schemes remained open. We advance this understanding on both the hardness and algorithmic fronts. We begin by showing that $k$-MSR is $W[2]$-hard parameterized by $k$, thereby pinpointing its location in the $W$-hierarchy. Moreover, via our reduction, we rule out efficient parameterized approximation schemes (EPAS)--that is, $(1+ε)$-approximations running in time $f(k,ε)\cdot \mathrm{poly}(n)$--unless $W[2] = FPT$. Assuming the Exponential Time Hypothesis, we further rule out such algorithms running in time $f(k,ε)\cdot n^{o(k)}$, strengthening recent lower bounds for the problem. On the algorithmic side, we study $k$-MSR under the framework of mergeable constraints, which captures a broad class of clustering constraints, including fairness, diversity, and lower bounds. We obtain an FPT $(\frac{8}{3}+ε)$-approximation, improving upon the previous best guarantee of $(4+ε)$. Moreover, given access to a suitable assignment subroutine, we achieve a $(2+ε)$-approximation, matching the best known bound for the unconstrained problem. This, in turn, yields $(2+ε)$ FPT-approximations for several important settings, including $(t,k)$-fair, $(α,β)$-fair, $\ell$-diversity, and private clustering.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

Designing Capacitated Subnetworks for Shortest Path Routing

Authors: Markus Chimani, Max Ilsen

In pursuit of higher energy efficiency in computer networks, one subfield of green traffic engineering aims at reducing the size of a network during times of low traffic, while still guaranteeing the ability to route all occurring demands. In this setting, we have to simultaneously solve a network design problem (choosing connections to deactivate) and a routing problem (routing paths in the active subnetwork, adhering to some routing protocol). Interestingly, there seems to be no available method to tackle the problem as a whole for the simplest (and still most commonly used) routing paradigm: shortest path routing. State-of-the-art methods either do not consider capacities, or assume that the routing paths should not change when deactivating network connections, or separate the problem into its two constituents, first solving the network design problem (using some estimators in lieu of the precise routing protocol) and only then the actual routing problem. In this paper, we present an algorithm to tackle the full combined problem exactly via a novel integer linear program, modeling dynamically changing shortest paths. To solve it, we need to devise a special-purpose column generation method. To speed up the solution process, we further propose additional provably strengthening constraints. Now having the means to yield true optimal solutions for (small) practical instances, we can for the first time give an in-depth experimental evaluation that includes the absolute quality intrinsic to the above simplifying algorithms. It turns out that the arguably simplest method--first computing a routing, fixing it, and turning off all superfluous connections--yields solutions surprisingly close to the true optimum in practice. When considering multiple different traffic demands, a recent traffic-oblivious approach (TOCA) performs best, while being comparatively straightforward to implement.

Authors: Markus Chimani, Max Ilsen

In pursuit of higher energy efficiency in computer networks, one subfield of green traffic engineering aims at reducing the size of a network during times of low traffic, while still guaranteeing the ability to route all occurring demands. In this setting, we have to simultaneously solve a network design problem (choosing connections to deactivate) and a routing problem (routing paths in the active subnetwork, adhering to some routing protocol). Interestingly, there seems to be no available method to tackle the problem as a whole for the simplest (and still most commonly used) routing paradigm: shortest path routing. State-of-the-art methods either do not consider capacities, or assume that the routing paths should not change when deactivating network connections, or separate the problem into its two constituents, first solving the network design problem (using some estimators in lieu of the precise routing protocol) and only then the actual routing problem. In this paper, we present an algorithm to tackle the full combined problem exactly via a novel integer linear program, modeling dynamically changing shortest paths. To solve it, we need to devise a special-purpose column generation method. To speed up the solution process, we further propose additional provably strengthening constraints. Now having the means to yield true optimal solutions for (small) practical instances, we can for the first time give an in-depth experimental evaluation that includes the absolute quality intrinsic to the above simplifying algorithms. It turns out that the arguably simplest method--first computing a routing, fixing it, and turning off all superfluous connections--yields solutions surprisingly close to the true optimum in practice. When considering multiple different traffic demands, a recent traffic-oblivious approach (TOCA) performs best, while being comparatively straightforward to implement.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

Contrastive Identification and Generation in the Limit

Authors: Xiaoyu Li, Andi Han, Jiaojiao Jiang, Junbin Gao

In the classical identification in the limit model of Gold [1967], a stream of positive examples is presented round by round, and the learner must eventually recover the target hypothesis. Recently, Kleinberg and Mullainathan [2024] introduced generation in the limit, where the learner instead must eventually output novel elements of the target's support. Both lines of work focus on positive-only or fully labeled data. Yet many natural supervision signals are inherently relational rather than singleton, which encode relationships between examples rather than labels of individual ones. We initiate the study of contrastive identification and generation in the limit, where the learner observes a contrastive presentation of data: a stream of unordered pairs $\{x,y\}$ satisfying $h(x)\ne h(y)$ for an unknown target binary hypothesis $h$, but which element is positive is hidden from the learner. We first present three results in the noiseless setting: an exact characterization of contrastive identifiable classes (a one-line geometric refinement of Angluin [1980]'s tell-tale condition), a combinatorial dimension called contrastive closure dimension (a contrasitive analogue of the closure dimension in Raman et al. [2025]) and exactly characterizing uniform contrastive generation with tight sample complexity, and a strict hierarchy in which contrastive generation and text identification are mutually incomparable. We then prove a sharp reversal under finite adversarial corruption: there exist classes identifiable from contrastive pairs under any finite corruption budget by a single budget-independent algorithm, yet not identifiable from positive examples under even one corrupted observation. The unifying technical object is the common crossing graph, which encodes pairwise ambiguity, family-level generation obstructions, and corruption defects in a single coverage-and-incidence language.

Authors: Xiaoyu Li, Andi Han, Jiaojiao Jiang, Junbin Gao

In the classical identification in the limit model of Gold [1967], a stream of positive examples is presented round by round, and the learner must eventually recover the target hypothesis. Recently, Kleinberg and Mullainathan [2024] introduced generation in the limit, where the learner instead must eventually output novel elements of the target's support. Both lines of work focus on positive-only or fully labeled data. Yet many natural supervision signals are inherently relational rather than singleton, which encode relationships between examples rather than labels of individual ones. We initiate the study of contrastive identification and generation in the limit, where the learner observes a contrastive presentation of data: a stream of unordered pairs $\{x,y\}$ satisfying $h(x)\ne h(y)$ for an unknown target binary hypothesis $h$, but which element is positive is hidden from the learner. We first present three results in the noiseless setting: an exact characterization of contrastive identifiable classes (a one-line geometric refinement of Angluin [1980]'s tell-tale condition), a combinatorial dimension called contrastive closure dimension (a contrasitive analogue of the closure dimension in Raman et al. [2025]) and exactly characterizing uniform contrastive generation with tight sample complexity, and a strict hierarchy in which contrastive generation and text identification are mutually incomparable. We then prove a sharp reversal under finite adversarial corruption: there exist classes identifiable from contrastive pairs under any finite corruption budget by a single budget-independent algorithm, yet not identifiable from positive examples under even one corrupted observation. The unifying technical object is the common crossing graph, which encodes pairwise ambiguity, family-level generation obstructions, and corruption defects in a single coverage-and-incidence language.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

The Pareto Frontier of Randomized Learning-Augmented Online Bidding

Authors: Mathis Degryse, Imrane Saakour, Christoph Dürr, Spyros Angelopoulos

Online bidding is a classical problem in online decision-making, with applications in resource allocation, hierarchical clustering, and the analysis of approximation algorithms. We study its randomized learning-augmented variant, where an online algorithm generates a sequence of random bids while leveraging predictions from an oracle. We provide analytical upper and lower bounds on the optimal consistency $C$ as a function of the robustness $R$, which match when $R \geq 2.885$, effectively closing the gap left by previous work. The key technical ingredient is the notion of a bidding function, a novel abstraction that provides a unified framework for the design and analysis of randomized bidding strategies. We complement our theoretical results with an experimental application of randomized bidding to the incremental median problem, demonstrating the applicability of our algorithm in practical clustering settings.

Authors: Mathis Degryse, Imrane Saakour, Christoph Dürr, Spyros Angelopoulos

Online bidding is a classical problem in online decision-making, with applications in resource allocation, hierarchical clustering, and the analysis of approximation algorithms. We study its randomized learning-augmented variant, where an online algorithm generates a sequence of random bids while leveraging predictions from an oracle. We provide analytical upper and lower bounds on the optimal consistency $C$ as a function of the robustness $R$, which match when $R \geq 2.885$, effectively closing the gap left by previous work. The key technical ingredient is the notion of a bidding function, a novel abstraction that provides a unified framework for the design and analysis of randomized bidding strategies. We complement our theoretical results with an experimental application of randomized bidding to the incremental median problem, demonstrating the applicability of our algorithm in practical clustering settings.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

Quantizing With Randomized Hadamard Transforms: Efficient Heuristic Now Proven

Authors: Ran Ben-Basat, William Kuszmaul, Michael Mitzenmacher, Amit Portnoy, Shay Vargaftik

Uniform random rotations (URRs) are a common preprocessing step in modern quantization approaches used for gradient compression, inference acceleration, KV-cache compression, model weight quantization, and approximate nearest-neighbor search in vector databases. In practice, URRs are often replaced by randomized Hadamard transforms (RHTs), which preserve orthogonality while admitting fast implementations. The remaining issue is the performance for worst-case inputs. With a URR, each coordinate is individually distributed as a shifted beta distribution, which converges to a Gaussian distribution in high dimensions. Generally, one RHT is not suitable in the worst case, as individual coordinates can be far from these distributions. We show that after composing two RHTs on any $d$-sized input vector, the marginal distribution of every fixed coordinate of the normalized rotated vector is within $O(d^{-1/2})$ of a standard Gaussian both in Kolmogorov distance and in $1$-Wasserstein distance. We then plug these bounds into the analyses of modern compression schemes, namely DRIVE and QUIC-FL, and show that two RHTs achieve performance that asymptotically matches URRs. However, we show that two RHTs may not be sufficient for Vector Quantization (VQ), which often requires weak correlation across fixed-size blocks of coordinates (as opposed to only marginal distribution convergence for single coordinates). We prove that a composition of three RHTs leads to decaying coordinate covariance. This ensures that any fixed, bounded, multi-dimensional VQ codebook optimized for URRs has the same expected error when using three RHTs, up to an additive term that vanishes with the dimension. Finally, because practical inputs are rarely adversarial, we propose a linear-time ${O}(d)$ check on the input's moments to dynamically adapt the number of RHTs used at runtime to improve performance.

Authors: Ran Ben-Basat, William Kuszmaul, Michael Mitzenmacher, Amit Portnoy, Shay Vargaftik

Uniform random rotations (URRs) are a common preprocessing step in modern quantization approaches used for gradient compression, inference acceleration, KV-cache compression, model weight quantization, and approximate nearest-neighbor search in vector databases. In practice, URRs are often replaced by randomized Hadamard transforms (RHTs), which preserve orthogonality while admitting fast implementations. The remaining issue is the performance for worst-case inputs. With a URR, each coordinate is individually distributed as a shifted beta distribution, which converges to a Gaussian distribution in high dimensions. Generally, one RHT is not suitable in the worst case, as individual coordinates can be far from these distributions. We show that after composing two RHTs on any $d$-sized input vector, the marginal distribution of every fixed coordinate of the normalized rotated vector is within $O(d^{-1/2})$ of a standard Gaussian both in Kolmogorov distance and in $1$-Wasserstein distance. We then plug these bounds into the analyses of modern compression schemes, namely DRIVE and QUIC-FL, and show that two RHTs achieve performance that asymptotically matches URRs. However, we show that two RHTs may not be sufficient for Vector Quantization (VQ), which often requires weak correlation across fixed-size blocks of coordinates (as opposed to only marginal distribution convergence for single coordinates). We prove that a composition of three RHTs leads to decaying coordinate covariance. This ensures that any fixed, bounded, multi-dimensional VQ codebook optimized for URRs has the same expected error when using three RHTs, up to an additive term that vanishes with the dimension. Finally, because practical inputs are rarely adversarial, we propose a linear-time ${O}(d)$ check on the input's moments to dynamically adapt the number of RHTs used at runtime to improve performance.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

Label Correcting Algorithms for the Multiobjective Temporal Shortest Path Problem

Authors: Edina Marica, Clemens Thielen, Alina Wittmann

Given a directed, discrete-time temporal graph $G=(V,R)$, a start node $s\in V$, and $p\geq1$ objectives, the single-source multiobjective temporal shortest path problem asks, for each $v\in V$, for the set of nondominated images of temporal $s$-$v$-paths together with a corresponding efficient path for each image. A recent general label setting algorithm for this problem relies on two properties of the objectives - monotonicity and isotonicity. Monotonicity generalizes the nonnegativity assumption required by label setting methods for the classical additive single-objective shortest path problem on static graphs, while isotonicity ensures that the order of the objective values of two paths is preserved when both are extended by the same arc. In this paper, we study the problem without assuming monotonicity and/or isotonicity. A key difficulty in this setting is that zero-duration temporal cycles may need to be traversed an arbitrary finite number of times to generate all nondominated images. This motivates the study of a restricted problem variant in which a maximum admissible path length $K$ is imposed, and only paths containing at most $K$ arcs are considered. We develop general label correcting algorithms for this setting and establish several sufficient conditions under which such a bound is not required, implying that the algorithms compute all nondominated images.

Authors: Edina Marica, Clemens Thielen, Alina Wittmann

Given a directed, discrete-time temporal graph $G=(V,R)$, a start node $s\in V$, and $p\geq1$ objectives, the single-source multiobjective temporal shortest path problem asks, for each $v\in V$, for the set of nondominated images of temporal $s$-$v$-paths together with a corresponding efficient path for each image. A recent general label setting algorithm for this problem relies on two properties of the objectives - monotonicity and isotonicity. Monotonicity generalizes the nonnegativity assumption required by label setting methods for the classical additive single-objective shortest path problem on static graphs, while isotonicity ensures that the order of the objective values of two paths is preserved when both are extended by the same arc. In this paper, we study the problem without assuming monotonicity and/or isotonicity. A key difficulty in this setting is that zero-duration temporal cycles may need to be traversed an arbitrary finite number of times to generate all nondominated images. This motivates the study of a restricted problem variant in which a maximum admissible path length $K$ is imposed, and only paths containing at most $K$ arcs are considered. We develop general label correcting algorithms for this setting and establish several sufficient conditions under which such a bound is not required, implying that the algorithms compute all nondominated images.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

Discrete Optimal Transport: Rapid Convergence of Simulated Annealing Algorithms

Authors: Yuchen He, Tianhui Jiang, Sihan Wang, Chihao Zhang

We develop a discrete optimal transport framework for analyzing simulated annealing algorithms on finite state spaces. Building on the discrete Wasserstein metric introduced by Maas (J. Funct. Anal., 2011), we define a generalized discrete Wasserstein-2 distance and the associated notion of \emph{discrete action} for paths of probability measures on graphs. Using these tools, we establish non-asymptotic convergence guarantees for simulated annealing: the KL divergence between the algorithm's output and the target distribution is controlled by the discrete action of the annealing path. This can be viewed as the discrete counterpart of the action-based analysis of annealed Langevin dynamics in continuous spaces by Guo, Tao, and Chen (ICLR 2025). As applications, we analyze simulated annealing for two fundamental models in statistical physics. For the \emph{mean-field Ising model}, we show that annealed single-site Glauber dynamics achieves $\varepsilon$ error in KL divergence in $O(n^5β^2/\varepsilon)$ steps at \emph{any} inverse temperature $β\ge 0$. For the \emph{mean-field $q$-state Potts model}, we show that annealed $(q-1)$-block Glauber dynamics achieves $\varepsilon$ error in $\mathrm{poly}(n, β, 1/\varepsilon)$ steps for all $β\ge β_{\mathsf{s}}=q/2$, the regime where the disordered phase has completely lost stability. In both cases, the key technical contribution is a polynomial upper bound on the discrete action, obtained by exploiting the symmetry of the model to reduce the analysis to a low-dimensional projected chain.

Authors: Yuchen He, Tianhui Jiang, Sihan Wang, Chihao Zhang

We develop a discrete optimal transport framework for analyzing simulated annealing algorithms on finite state spaces. Building on the discrete Wasserstein metric introduced by Maas (J. Funct. Anal., 2011), we define a generalized discrete Wasserstein-2 distance and the associated notion of \emph{discrete action} for paths of probability measures on graphs. Using these tools, we establish non-asymptotic convergence guarantees for simulated annealing: the KL divergence between the algorithm's output and the target distribution is controlled by the discrete action of the annealing path. This can be viewed as the discrete counterpart of the action-based analysis of annealed Langevin dynamics in continuous spaces by Guo, Tao, and Chen (ICLR 2025). As applications, we analyze simulated annealing for two fundamental models in statistical physics. For the \emph{mean-field Ising model}, we show that annealed single-site Glauber dynamics achieves $\varepsilon$ error in KL divergence in $O(n^5β^2/\varepsilon)$ steps at \emph{any} inverse temperature $β\ge 0$. For the \emph{mean-field $q$-state Potts model}, we show that annealed $(q-1)$-block Glauber dynamics achieves $\varepsilon$ error in $\mathrm{poly}(n, β, 1/\varepsilon)$ steps for all $β\ge β_{\mathsf{s}}=q/2$, the regime where the disordered phase has completely lost stability. In both cases, the key technical contribution is a polynomial upper bound on the discrete action, obtained by exploiting the symmetry of the model to reduce the analysis to a low-dimensional projected chain.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

An Additive Approximation Scheme for Generating Dyadic Codings for the Outputs of an LLM

Authors: Daniella Bar-Lev, Farzad Farnoud, Ryan Gabrys

We study the problem of approximating a discrete probability distribution, such as the next-token distribution of a large language model, by a dyadic distribution induced by a binary tree under encoding rate constraints. The objective is to partition the support of the distribution and assign dyadic probabilities to minimize total variation distance while achieving a prescribed rate. We formulate this task as a tree-based partitioning problem and develop a polynomial-time additive approximation scheme for the rate-constrained setting in the constant-rate regime. Our results provide provable guarantees for near-optimal dyadic approximations and, as an application, yield a principled framework for LLM-based steganography, where the rate maps to bits of hidden information embedded per token and the total variation bound controls statistical detectability.

Authors: Daniella Bar-Lev, Farzad Farnoud, Ryan Gabrys

We study the problem of approximating a discrete probability distribution, such as the next-token distribution of a large language model, by a dyadic distribution induced by a binary tree under encoding rate constraints. The objective is to partition the support of the distribution and assign dyadic probabilities to minimize total variation distance while achieving a prescribed rate. We formulate this task as a tree-based partitioning problem and develop a polynomial-time additive approximation scheme for the rate-constrained setting in the constant-rate regime. Our results provide provable guarantees for near-optimal dyadic approximations and, as an application, yield a principled framework for LLM-based steganography, where the rate maps to bits of hidden information embedded per token and the total variation bound controls statistical detectability.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

Nearly Optimal Attention Coresets

Authors: Edo Liberty, Alexandr Andoni, Eldar Kleiner

We consider the problem of estimating the Attention mechanism in small space, and prove the existence of coresets for it of nearly optimal size. Specifically, we show that for any set of unit-norm keys and values $(K,V)$ in $\mathbb{R}^d$, there exists a subset $(K',V')$ of size at most $O({\sqrt{d} e^{ρ+o(ρ)}/\varepsilon})$ such that \[ \left\| \operatorname{Attn}(q,K,V)- \operatorname{Attn}(q,K',V') \right\| \le \varepsilon \] simultaneously for all queries whose norm is bounded by $ρ$. This outperforms the best known results for this problem. We also offer an improved lower bound showing that $\varepsilon$-coresets must have size $Ω({\sqrt{d} e^ρ/ε})$.

Authors: Edo Liberty, Alexandr Andoni, Eldar Kleiner

We consider the problem of estimating the Attention mechanism in small space, and prove the existence of coresets for it of nearly optimal size. Specifically, we show that for any set of unit-norm keys and values $(K,V)$ in $\mathbb{R}^d$, there exists a subset $(K',V')$ of size at most $O({\sqrt{d} e^{ρ+o(ρ)}/\varepsilon})$ such that \[ \left\| \operatorname{Attn}(q,K,V)- \operatorname{Attn}(q,K',V') \right\| \le \varepsilon \] simultaneously for all queries whose norm is bounded by $ρ$. This outperforms the best known results for this problem. We also offer an improved lower bound showing that $\varepsilon$-coresets must have size $Ω({\sqrt{d} e^ρ/ε})$.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

A Separator for Minor-Free Graphs Beyond the Flow Barrier

Authors: Hung Le

In 1990, Alon, Seymour, and Thomas gave the first balanced separator of size $O(h^{3/2}\sqrt{n})$ for any $K_h$-minor-free graph, which has had numerous algorithmic applications. They conjectured that the size of the balanced separator can be reduced to $O(h\sqrt{n})$, which is asymptotically tight. Two decades later, Kawarabayashi and Reed constructed a separator of size $O(h\sqrt{n} + f(h))$ based on the graph minor structure theorem, where $f(h)$ is an extremely fast-growing function; their separator's size is only better for a very small value of $h$. Recently, Spalding-Jamieson constructed a separator of size $O(h\log h \log\log h \sqrt{n})$; the technique is rooted in concurrent flow-sparsest cut duality. Spalding-Jamieson's separator comes very close to $O(h\log h \sqrt{n})$, which is the barrier for techniques based on the flow-cut duality. In this work, we first present a simple adaptation of a flow-based algorithm of Korhonen and Lokshtanov to construct a balanced separator of size $O(h\log h \sqrt{n})$, matching the flow barrier. This result motivates the question of whether the flow barrier can be broken, which would be a stepping stone toward resolving the conjecture of Alon, Seymour, and Thomas. The main result of our work is a positive answer to this question: we construct a balanced separator of size $O(h \sqrt{\log h} \sqrt{n})$. Surprisingly, perhaps, our algorithm is still based on the iterative framework of Alon, Seymour, and Thomas, although a key component of their algorithm within this framework, called the neighborhood bound, was shown to be tight. Our new idea is to incorporate a low-diameter decomposition into the framework, allowing us to reduce the neighborhood bound by a factor of $h$, at the cost of a factor $\log h$, which translates to a reduction from $\sqrt{h}$ to $\sqrt{\log h}$ in the final separator's size.

Authors: Hung Le

In 1990, Alon, Seymour, and Thomas gave the first balanced separator of size $O(h^{3/2}\sqrt{n})$ for any $K_h$-minor-free graph, which has had numerous algorithmic applications. They conjectured that the size of the balanced separator can be reduced to $O(h\sqrt{n})$, which is asymptotically tight. Two decades later, Kawarabayashi and Reed constructed a separator of size $O(h\sqrt{n} + f(h))$ based on the graph minor structure theorem, where $f(h)$ is an extremely fast-growing function; their separator's size is only better for a very small value of $h$. Recently, Spalding-Jamieson constructed a separator of size $O(h\log h \log\log h \sqrt{n})$; the technique is rooted in concurrent flow-sparsest cut duality. Spalding-Jamieson's separator comes very close to $O(h\log h \sqrt{n})$, which is the barrier for techniques based on the flow-cut duality. In this work, we first present a simple adaptation of a flow-based algorithm of Korhonen and Lokshtanov to construct a balanced separator of size $O(h\log h \sqrt{n})$, matching the flow barrier. This result motivates the question of whether the flow barrier can be broken, which would be a stepping stone toward resolving the conjecture of Alon, Seymour, and Thomas. The main result of our work is a positive answer to this question: we construct a balanced separator of size $O(h \sqrt{\log h} \sqrt{n})$. Surprisingly, perhaps, our algorithm is still based on the iterative framework of Alon, Seymour, and Thomas, although a key component of their algorithm within this framework, called the neighborhood bound, was shown to be tight. Our new idea is to incorporate a low-diameter decomposition into the framework, allowing us to reduce the neighborhood bound by a factor of $h$, at the cost of a factor $\log h$, which translates to a reduction from $\sqrt{h}$ to $\sqrt{\log h}$ in the final separator's size.

Friday, May 08 2026, 00:00

The Rationality of the Language Machines

from Ben Recht

Are LLMs mathematically rational?

My least favorite part of writing books is their permanence. Minutes after I spend time with a hardcopy, I start seeing a bunch of things I should have added, removed, or modified. I’m not talking about typos—I expect and accept those will be abundant—but rather ways I’d have written the book differently if I could do it again. In particular, this last week of Irrational Decision events crystallized a few things that I wish I had commented on, but maybe couldn’t have.

I’ll spend the next few blog posts going over the questions raised that I wish I had addressed in the book. I was unhappy with my extemporaneous replies, and I’m hoping blogging might bring me more satisfactory answers.

I’ll start with the trillion-dollar elephant in the room: language machines. In our conversation on Tuesday, Lily Hu asked me how LLMs denote a shift away from the mathematical rationality of The Irrational Decision. For a long time, artificial intelligence systems were built by solving problems differently from how people solved them. For example, computers are better at chess than humans, but they do not approximate the way master chess players play. But LLMs, especially the chatbot interaction model that captured global attention and rocketed the valuations of these companies into the stratosphere, uncannily seem to act and respond like us. This seems like a departure from the cold rationality of computation.

The chat interface leans on the ambiguity of language to make for a satisfying interactive experience. Joseph Weizenbaum famously lamented that when his colleagues tried to make a computer appear intelligent, they leaned on psychological parlor tricks. A machine that summarizes in iambic pentameter appears intelligent. A machine that solves a linear program in millions of variables is merely mechanically calculating.

So what does it mean to lean on language machines for decision making? This is a tricky question because LLMs are unfathomably complex software artifacts. If you use them under the harness of a coding agent, you can get them to optimize all sorts of things. For example, they are incredible at making code faster, outperforming any autotuning tool I’ve ever tried. You can easily get them to implement a Bayesian rational choice engine for you.

Certainly, the rationalist weirdos in charge at Anthropic have demanded that Claude be trained to recite back summaries of dogma from the lesswrong.com comments section. So LLMs can and will parrot back the tenets of mathematical rationality to you. But natural language is not rational language. Indeed, the language of mathematical rationality is a Bayesian language game, always working to box out the unmeasurable and unquantifiable. It demands language without ambiguity, but of course, language is always ambiguous, fluid, and evolving.

You can try to squeeze out the ambiguity by prompting the machines to reply in logically structured language, like software or mathematics. Yet, even when you try to get the chat interfaces to give you rational answers, you still find perplexing mistakes that aren’t even logical, let alone rational. I liked this glaringly obvious one from last week.

These sorts of errors remain vexingly common, but are becoming increasingly difficult to spot.

The coding machines I mentioned above, with their ability to execute, check errors, and optimize, feel like they are more rational. However, they force programmers to cosplay as project managers. Software engineers have to prompt in natural language that is kind, inspiring, and encouraging. There are massively popular GitHub repos that help you find the right phrasing to make sure your eager agents have the right artificial mindset so they don’t make mistakes. This doesn’t seem very mathematically rational either.

Moreover, in the broader context of decision making, the vast majority of people do not have LLMs write optimization code to compute the decisions for them. Instead, they treat the chat like a consultant, and get interactive text back, sometimes with charts and figures for quantified comfort. Being advised by these outputs as to how to structure your life or business is closer to a magic eight ball than to a linear program. Writing in imprecise language and having a system trained to respond nicely certainly isn’t mathematical rationality. It’s what the early mathematicians tried to excise from decision making. What a weird turn.

But if we step back from the chat box, it’s not hard to place LLMs on a linear axis of mathematical rationality. The people who build these things religiously believe in mathematical rationality. They endorse the Bostrom-Russell nonsense that intelligence is attached to singular objective functions, and our robots will kill our dogs to make us coffee. Alignment researchers claim we just have to find the right objective function for post-training, and then we’ll have perfect human companions to build us a utopia of abundance.

Similarly, the guts of LLMs are the same computational pillars I describe in the book. LLMs seem like us, but they are still built upon the very unnatural model of statistically summarizing language and code via maximum likelihood estimation. People don’t do this.

Language machines run on complex software, hardware, and network infrastructure, but none of it would look alien to a computer engineer from 2006. Just like every computing system of the past two decades, they are tuned by optimizing engagement, maximizing userbase preferences in glorified A/B tests. The advances are charted by the same sort of rational, average-case benchmarking we’ve been doing in machine learning for decades. We make them better by blindly optimizing without understanding.

And let us not forget that these products were built upon fraud, theft, and rent extraction. They are enriching a small group of incredibly annoying people who claim a mantle of mathematical rationality and are promising to subjugate the rest of us in unemployment work camps. Though I started this blog lamenting what I didn’t cover in The Irrational Decision, maybe I got this one right: That we built this wildly irrational technology with mathematical rationality corroborates my argument.

Subscribe now

By Ben Recht

Thursday, May 07 2026, 14:39

Average Attention Transformers and Arithmetic Circuits

Authors: Lena Ehrmuth, Laura Strieker

We analyse the computational power of transformer encoders as sequence-to-sequence functions on vectors. We show that average hard attention can be used to simulate arithmetic circuits if they are given as an input to an encoder. The circuit families that can be simulated this way have constant depth while using unbounded addition, binary multiplication and sign gates. The transformers we use have arithmetic circuits instead of feed-forward networks. With typical average attention the functions they compute are also computed by the same class of circuit families. Our results hold for transformers over the reals, rationals and any ring in between the two.

Authors: Lena Ehrmuth, Laura Strieker

We analyse the computational power of transformer encoders as sequence-to-sequence functions on vectors. We show that average hard attention can be used to simulate arithmetic circuits if they are given as an input to an encoder. The circuit families that can be simulated this way have constant depth while using unbounded addition, binary multiplication and sign gates. The transformers we use have arithmetic circuits instead of feed-forward networks. With typical average attention the functions they compute are also computed by the same class of circuit families. Our results hold for transformers over the reals, rationals and any ring in between the two.

Thursday, May 07 2026, 00:00

Hard CNF Instances for Ideal Proof Systems

Authors: Tuomas Hakoniemi, Nutan Limaye, Iddo Tzameret

Since the introduction of the Ideal Proof System (IPS) by Grochow and Pitassi (J. ACM 2018), a substantial body of work has established size lower bounds for IPS and its fragments. In particular, Forbes, Shpilka, Tzameret, and Wigderson (Theory Comput. 2021) developed the main lower-bound frameworks for restricted IPS fragments, namely functional lower bounds and the hard multiples method, while Alekseev, Grigoriev, Hirsch, and Tzameret (SIAM J. Comput. 2024) gave a general template for conditional lower bounds for full IPS. Yet all these lower bounds apply only to purely algebraic formulas over a field, that is, non-Boolean formulas not directly expressible in propositional logic. Proving lower bounds for CNF formulas has therefore remained a central open problem in this line of work. The current work resolves this question for IPS over read-once oblivious algebraic branching programs (roABPs) by proving lower bounds for refutations of CNF formulas in this system. Our approach is a rank-based feasible interpolation argument, following the method of Pudlák and Sgall (Proof Complexity and Feasible Arithmetic 1996) for monotone span programs, in which decomposing a given roABP refutation along a variable partition yields a low-dimensional space of polynomials from which we construct a span-program interpolant. We extend their result from Nullstellensatz refutations measured by degree to Nullstellensatz refutations measured by roABP size (i.e., roABP-IPS$_\text{LIN}$).

Authors: Tuomas Hakoniemi, Nutan Limaye, Iddo Tzameret

Since the introduction of the Ideal Proof System (IPS) by Grochow and Pitassi (J. ACM 2018), a substantial body of work has established size lower bounds for IPS and its fragments. In particular, Forbes, Shpilka, Tzameret, and Wigderson (Theory Comput. 2021) developed the main lower-bound frameworks for restricted IPS fragments, namely functional lower bounds and the hard multiples method, while Alekseev, Grigoriev, Hirsch, and Tzameret (SIAM J. Comput. 2024) gave a general template for conditional lower bounds for full IPS. Yet all these lower bounds apply only to purely algebraic formulas over a field, that is, non-Boolean formulas not directly expressible in propositional logic. Proving lower bounds for CNF formulas has therefore remained a central open problem in this line of work. The current work resolves this question for IPS over read-once oblivious algebraic branching programs (roABPs) by proving lower bounds for refutations of CNF formulas in this system. Our approach is a rank-based feasible interpolation argument, following the method of Pudlák and Sgall (Proof Complexity and Feasible Arithmetic 1996) for monotone span programs, in which decomposing a given roABP refutation along a variable partition yields a low-dimensional space of polynomials from which we construct a span-program interpolant. We extend their result from Nullstellensatz refutations measured by degree to Nullstellensatz refutations measured by roABP size (i.e., roABP-IPS$_\text{LIN}$).

Thursday, May 07 2026, 00:00

The Scaling Properties of Implicit Deductive Reasoning in Transformers

Authors: Enrico Vompa, Tanel Tammet

We investigate the scaling properties of implicit deductive reasoning over Horn clauses in depth-bounded Transformers. By systematically decorrelating provability from spurious features and enforcing algorithmic alignment, we find that in sufficiently deep models with a bidirectional prefix mask, implicit reasoning approaches explicit CoT performance across graph topologies and problem widths, though CoT remains necessary for depth extrapolation.

Authors: Enrico Vompa, Tanel Tammet

We investigate the scaling properties of implicit deductive reasoning over Horn clauses in depth-bounded Transformers. By systematically decorrelating provability from spurious features and enforcing algorithmic alignment, we find that in sufficiently deep models with a bidirectional prefix mask, implicit reasoning approaches explicit CoT performance across graph topologies and problem widths, though CoT remains necessary for depth extrapolation.

Thursday, May 07 2026, 00:00

Rigid homotopies for sampling from algebraic varieties: a Waring structure complexity model

Authors: Abigail R. Jones, Kisun Lee, Jose Israel Rodriguez

Polynomial system solving has seen major progress in both theory and practice over the past decade. A landmark achievement was addressing Smale's 17th problem, establishing average-case polynomial-time algorithms for computing approximate solutions of polynomial systems via homotopy continuation. Recent improvements in complexity bounds for these algorithms led to the development of rigid homotopy methods. In this article, we prove a new complexity result for rigid homotopies for polynomial systems with Waring representations of prescribed length. In addition, we provide the first computational experiments for rigid homotopies using a preliminary implementation.

Authors: Abigail R. Jones, Kisun Lee, Jose Israel Rodriguez

Polynomial system solving has seen major progress in both theory and practice over the past decade. A landmark achievement was addressing Smale's 17th problem, establishing average-case polynomial-time algorithms for computing approximate solutions of polynomial systems via homotopy continuation. Recent improvements in complexity bounds for these algorithms led to the development of rigid homotopy methods. In this article, we prove a new complexity result for rigid homotopies for polynomial systems with Waring representations of prescribed length. In addition, we provide the first computational experiments for rigid homotopies using a preliminary implementation.

Thursday, May 07 2026, 00:00

On the Complexity of Minimum Riesz s-Energy Subset Selection in Euclidean and Ultrametric Spaces

Authors: Michael T. M. Emmerich, Ksenia Pereverdieva, André Deutz

We study the computational complexity of exact cardinality-constrained minimum Riesz $s$-energy subset selection in finite metric spaces: given $n$ points, select $k

Authors: Michael T. M. Emmerich, Ksenia Pereverdieva, André Deutz

We study the computational complexity of exact cardinality-constrained minimum Riesz $s$-energy subset selection in finite metric spaces: given $n$ points, select $k

Thursday, May 07 2026, 00:00

Online Orthogonal Vectors Revisited

Authors: Karthik Gajulapalli, Alexander Golovnev, Samuel King, Sidhant Saraogi

We prove new upper and lower bounds for the Online Orthogonal Vectors Problem ($\mathsf{OnlineOV}_{n,d}$). In this problem, a preprocessing algorithm receives $n$ vectors $x_1,\ldots,x_n\in\{0,1\}^d$ and constructs a data structure of size $S$. A query algorithm subsequently receives a query vector $q\in\{0,1\}^d$ and in time $T$ decides whether $q$ is orthogonal to any of the input vectors $x_i$. We design a new deterministic data structure for $\mathsf{OnlineOV}_{n,d}$. In low dimensions ($d = c \log n$), our data structure matches the performance of the best known randomized algorithm due to Chan [SoCG 2017]. Furthermore, in moderate dimensions ($d=n^{\varepsilon}$), we give the first improvement since Charikar, Indyk and Panigrahy [ICALP 2002]. Along the way, we give the first deterministic refutation of a conjecture on the hardness of $\mathsf{OnlineOV}$ posed by Goldstein, Lewenstein and Porat [ISAAC 2017]. This data structure also extends to a number of problems, including Partial Match, Orthogonal Range Search, and DNF Evaluation. We use a novel structure-versus-randomness decomposition to design our algorithm. Under the Non-Uniform Strong Exponential Time Hypothesis, we also prove arbitrarily large polynomial space lower bounds for any $\mathsf{OnlineOV}$ data structure with sublinear query time even with computationally unbounded preprocessing. These lower bounds extend to several other problems, including Polynomial Evaluation, Partial Match, Orthogonal Range Search, and Approximate Nearest Neighbors. We also prove similar lower bounds for $\mathsf{3-SUM}$ with preprocessing under the Non-Uniform Hamiltonian Path Conjecture.

Authors: Karthik Gajulapalli, Alexander Golovnev, Samuel King, Sidhant Saraogi

We prove new upper and lower bounds for the Online Orthogonal Vectors Problem ($\mathsf{OnlineOV}_{n,d}$). In this problem, a preprocessing algorithm receives $n$ vectors $x_1,\ldots,x_n\in\{0,1\}^d$ and constructs a data structure of size $S$. A query algorithm subsequently receives a query vector $q\in\{0,1\}^d$ and in time $T$ decides whether $q$ is orthogonal to any of the input vectors $x_i$. We design a new deterministic data structure for $\mathsf{OnlineOV}_{n,d}$. In low dimensions ($d = c \log n$), our data structure matches the performance of the best known randomized algorithm due to Chan [SoCG 2017]. Furthermore, in moderate dimensions ($d=n^{\varepsilon}$), we give the first improvement since Charikar, Indyk and Panigrahy [ICALP 2002]. Along the way, we give the first deterministic refutation of a conjecture on the hardness of $\mathsf{OnlineOV}$ posed by Goldstein, Lewenstein and Porat [ISAAC 2017]. This data structure also extends to a number of problems, including Partial Match, Orthogonal Range Search, and DNF Evaluation. We use a novel structure-versus-randomness decomposition to design our algorithm. Under the Non-Uniform Strong Exponential Time Hypothesis, we also prove arbitrarily large polynomial space lower bounds for any $\mathsf{OnlineOV}$ data structure with sublinear query time even with computationally unbounded preprocessing. These lower bounds extend to several other problems, including Polynomial Evaluation, Partial Match, Orthogonal Range Search, and Approximate Nearest Neighbors. We also prove similar lower bounds for $\mathsf{3-SUM}$ with preprocessing under the Non-Uniform Hamiltonian Path Conjecture.

Thursday, May 07 2026, 00:00

Block Permutation Routing on Ramanujan Hypergraphs for Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computing

Authors: Joshua M. Courtney

We analyze permutation routing of rigid blocks representing surface code patches of $d_C^2$ atoms on a reconfigurable lattice with hypergraph transformations. For a hypergraph $H$, code distance $d_C$, $s=d_C^2$, number of blocks $N_L$, and guard distance $g$, we show the block routing number $\mathrm{rt}_B(H, s, g) = Θ(d_C \log N_L)$. A spectral analysis of the quotient graph $Q(G_{\mathrm{cl}}(H), B)$ (blocks as supervertices) shows that the spectral ratio $β_Q < 1$ is preserved in the high-connectivity regime. Negative association of block permutations and congestion bounds are used for random intermediate configurations. Serialization establishes that each quotient routing phase requires $O(d_C)$ physical sub-steps due to the block footprint width. A lower bound $\mathrm{rt}_B = Ω(d_C \log N_L)$ follows from combining the spectral lower bound on quotient phases with the traversal cost per phase. We include error model analysis grounded in recent experimental results, syndrome extraction protocols (stop-and-correct, rolling active fault-tolerant (AFT) measurement, and adaptive deformation), and integration with lattice surgery compilation via the Litinski protocol. Composition with the correlated-decoding scheme reduces syndrome-extraction overhead from $O(d_C)$ to $O(1)$ per correction window, leaving routing as the leading-order contributor to the integrated $O(d_C \log N_L)$ depth. Spectral inheritance is organized in a hierarchy: exact (Haemers interlacing on equitable partitions), perturbative (Weyl bounds for near-equitable partitions, a practically relevant case for surface-code patches), and universal (higher-order Cheeger). Methods extend directly to QCCD trapped-ion architectures under the same regime condition, with junction crossings replacing AOD transports as the elementary single-hop translation.

Authors: Joshua M. Courtney

We analyze permutation routing of rigid blocks representing surface code patches of $d_C^2$ atoms on a reconfigurable lattice with hypergraph transformations. For a hypergraph $H$, code distance $d_C$, $s=d_C^2$, number of blocks $N_L$, and guard distance $g$, we show the block routing number $\mathrm{rt}_B(H, s, g) = Θ(d_C \log N_L)$. A spectral analysis of the quotient graph $Q(G_{\mathrm{cl}}(H), B)$ (blocks as supervertices) shows that the spectral ratio $β_Q < 1$ is preserved in the high-connectivity regime. Negative association of block permutations and congestion bounds are used for random intermediate configurations. Serialization establishes that each quotient routing phase requires $O(d_C)$ physical sub-steps due to the block footprint width. A lower bound $\mathrm{rt}_B = Ω(d_C \log N_L)$ follows from combining the spectral lower bound on quotient phases with the traversal cost per phase. We include error model analysis grounded in recent experimental results, syndrome extraction protocols (stop-and-correct, rolling active fault-tolerant (AFT) measurement, and adaptive deformation), and integration with lattice surgery compilation via the Litinski protocol. Composition with the correlated-decoding scheme reduces syndrome-extraction overhead from $O(d_C)$ to $O(1)$ per correction window, leaving routing as the leading-order contributor to the integrated $O(d_C \log N_L)$ depth. Spectral inheritance is organized in a hierarchy: exact (Haemers interlacing on equitable partitions), perturbative (Weyl bounds for near-equitable partitions, a practically relevant case for surface-code patches), and universal (higher-order Cheeger). Methods extend directly to QCCD trapped-ion architectures under the same regime condition, with junction crossings replacing AOD transports as the elementary single-hop translation.

Thursday, May 07 2026, 00:00

Faster Algorithms for Shortest Unique or Absent Substrings

Authors: Panagiotis Charalampopoulos, Manal Mohamed, Solon P. Pissis, Hilde Verbeek, Wiktor Zuba

We revisit two well-known algorithmic problems on strings: computing a shortest unique substring (SUS) and a shortest absent substring (SAS) of a string $S$ of length $n$. Both problems admit folklore $\mathcal{O}(n)$-time solutions using the suffix tree of $S$. However, for small alphabets, this complexity is not necessarily optimal in the word RAM model, where a string of length $n$ over alphabet $[0,σ)$ can be stored in $\mathcal{O}(n \log σ/\log n)$ space and read in $\mathcal{O}(n \log σ/\log n)$ time. We present an $\mathcal{O}(n \log σ/\sqrt{\log n})$-time algorithm for computing a SUS of $S$. This algorithm decomposes the problem according to the length and the period of the sought substring and uses several tools and techniques, such as synchronizing sets, the analysis of runs, and wavelet trees, to reduce the computation of a SUS to a simple geometric problem. Further, we adapt this algorithm and combine it with an efficient construction of de Bruijn sequences in order to obtain an $\mathcal{O}(n \log σ/\sqrt{\log n})$-time algorithm for computing a SAS of $S$.

Authors: Panagiotis Charalampopoulos, Manal Mohamed, Solon P. Pissis, Hilde Verbeek, Wiktor Zuba

We revisit two well-known algorithmic problems on strings: computing a shortest unique substring (SUS) and a shortest absent substring (SAS) of a string $S$ of length $n$. Both problems admit folklore $\mathcal{O}(n)$-time solutions using the suffix tree of $S$. However, for small alphabets, this complexity is not necessarily optimal in the word RAM model, where a string of length $n$ over alphabet $[0,σ)$ can be stored in $\mathcal{O}(n \log σ/\log n)$ space and read in $\mathcal{O}(n \log σ/\log n)$ time. We present an $\mathcal{O}(n \log σ/\sqrt{\log n})$-time algorithm for computing a SUS of $S$. This algorithm decomposes the problem according to the length and the period of the sought substring and uses several tools and techniques, such as synchronizing sets, the analysis of runs, and wavelet trees, to reduce the computation of a SUS to a simple geometric problem. Further, we adapt this algorithm and combine it with an efficient construction of de Bruijn sequences in order to obtain an $\mathcal{O}(n \log σ/\sqrt{\log n})$-time algorithm for computing a SAS of $S$.

Thursday, May 07 2026, 00:00

Robust Inverse Quadratic Error Decay with Meshing and Beam Search for Random Subset Sum

Authors: Edwin Chen, Christof Teuscher

The Subset Sum Problem is a fundamental NP-complete problem in cryptography and combinatorial optimization, with many real-world applications. The Random Subset Sum Problem (RSSP) is a more applicable version of subset sum, where numbers are drawn from some i.i.d input distribution. We present an algorithm that, with probability $1-δ$, constructs the same $O(B/w)$ mesh as Da Cunha et al. (2023), while trimming to $w$ elements throughout and running in $O(w\log w)$ time. Then, we present a novel beam search heuristic running in linearithmic time w.r.t list size $n$ and beam width $w$ using the mesh that gives an expected error of $O\!\left(\frac{B}{nw^2}\right)$ under a standard mean-field assumption with equal standard deviation, demonstrating the practical effectiveness of meshing to achieve error decay. The algorithm is empirically robust to multiple input distributions and can naturally extend to variants with simple changes to the scoring heuristic, establishing a new practical baseline for robust subset sum error decay and $ε$-approximation theory.

Authors: Edwin Chen, Christof Teuscher

The Subset Sum Problem is a fundamental NP-complete problem in cryptography and combinatorial optimization, with many real-world applications. The Random Subset Sum Problem (RSSP) is a more applicable version of subset sum, where numbers are drawn from some i.i.d input distribution. We present an algorithm that, with probability $1-δ$, constructs the same $O(B/w)$ mesh as Da Cunha et al. (2023), while trimming to $w$ elements throughout and running in $O(w\log w)$ time. Then, we present a novel beam search heuristic running in linearithmic time w.r.t list size $n$ and beam width $w$ using the mesh that gives an expected error of $O\!\left(\frac{B}{nw^2}\right)$ under a standard mean-field assumption with equal standard deviation, demonstrating the practical effectiveness of meshing to achieve error decay. The algorithm is empirically robust to multiple input distributions and can naturally extend to variants with simple changes to the scoring heuristic, establishing a new practical baseline for robust subset sum error decay and $ε$-approximation theory.

Thursday, May 07 2026, 00:00

Submodular Ground-Set Pruning: Monotone Tightness and a Non-Monotone Separation

Authors: Alan Kuhnle

Large-scale subset selection asks for a small useful set of examples, features, sensors, seed users, or context passages from an enormous ground set. Submodular maximization is a canonical model for such diminishing-returns problems, but rapidly growing datasets make even linear-time algorithms ever costlier. We study \emph{containment pruning}: first reduce the ground set to a smaller core $P$, then require that $P$ contain a near-optimal feasible solution for every downstream budget up to~$k$. Prior work has formulated many heuristics, but the theoretical limits of this preprocessing problem are largely unknown. For monotone submodular objectives, we prove that $1-1/e$ is tight: greedy achieves this containment factor, and no algorithm can beat it even with a larger pruning budget. For non-monotone objectives, we give the first$1/2-\varepsilon$ containment algorithms under cardinality constraints and extend the approach to knapsack constraints. This $1/2$ factor exceeds the best known algorithmic ratio and the known hardness threshold for non-monotone maximization, showing that pruning can be provably easier than optimization. Empirically, pruning lets an exact IP solver run on the reduced MaxCut instance with a ${\approx}620\times$ speedup, and proof-of-concept experiments on LLM context selection demonstrate the utility of non-monotone submodular proxies and our proposed containment algorithms.

Authors: Alan Kuhnle

Large-scale subset selection asks for a small useful set of examples, features, sensors, seed users, or context passages from an enormous ground set. Submodular maximization is a canonical model for such diminishing-returns problems, but rapidly growing datasets make even linear-time algorithms ever costlier. We study \emph{containment pruning}: first reduce the ground set to a smaller core $P$, then require that $P$ contain a near-optimal feasible solution for every downstream budget up to~$k$. Prior work has formulated many heuristics, but the theoretical limits of this preprocessing problem are largely unknown. For monotone submodular objectives, we prove that $1-1/e$ is tight: greedy achieves this containment factor, and no algorithm can beat it even with a larger pruning budget. For non-monotone objectives, we give the first$1/2-\varepsilon$ containment algorithms under cardinality constraints and extend the approach to knapsack constraints. This $1/2$ factor exceeds the best known algorithmic ratio and the known hardness threshold for non-monotone maximization, showing that pruning can be provably easier than optimization. Empirically, pruning lets an exact IP solver run on the reduced MaxCut instance with a ${\approx}620\times$ speedup, and proof-of-concept experiments on LLM context selection demonstrate the utility of non-monotone submodular proxies and our proposed containment algorithms.

Thursday, May 07 2026, 00:00

Constructing Suffixient Arrays Revisited

Authors: Paola Bonizzoni, Younan Gao, Brian Riccardi

Recently, Cenzato et al.\ proposed a new text index, called the \emph{suffixient array}, which is a subset of the suffix array and supports locating a single pattern occurrence or finding its maximal exact matches (MEMs), assuming random access to the input text $T[1..n]$ is available. They show that, given the suffix array, the longest common prefix array, and the Burrows--Wheeler transform (BWT) of the reverse of $T[1..n]$ over an alphabet $\{1,\ldots,σ\}$, a suffixient array can be constructed in linear time. However, their construction algorithms require multiple scans of these arrays. When restricted to a single pass over the arrays, they present an alternative construction algorithm running in $O(n + \overline{r} \log σ)$ time, where $\overline{r}$ is the number of runs in the BWT of the reversed text. In this paper, we present a new one-pass algorithm that constructs a suffixient array in linear time under the standard RAM model.

Authors: Paola Bonizzoni, Younan Gao, Brian Riccardi

Recently, Cenzato et al.\ proposed a new text index, called the \emph{suffixient array}, which is a subset of the suffix array and supports locating a single pattern occurrence or finding its maximal exact matches (MEMs), assuming random access to the input text $T[1..n]$ is available. They show that, given the suffix array, the longest common prefix array, and the Burrows--Wheeler transform (BWT) of the reverse of $T[1..n]$ over an alphabet $\{1,\ldots,σ\}$, a suffixient array can be constructed in linear time. However, their construction algorithms require multiple scans of these arrays. When restricted to a single pass over the arrays, they present an alternative construction algorithm running in $O(n + \overline{r} \log σ)$ time, where $\overline{r}$ is the number of runs in the BWT of the reversed text. In this paper, we present a new one-pass algorithm that constructs a suffixient array in linear time under the standard RAM model.

Thursday, May 07 2026, 00:00

Faster Iterative $φ$ Queries on the Positional BWT

Authors: Paola Bonizzoni, Travis Gagie, Younan Gao

The Positional Burrows-Wheeler Transform (PBWT) is a fundamental data structure for the efficient representation and analysis of large-scale haplotype panels. For a panel of $h$ sequences $\{S_1, \dots, S_h\}$ over $m$ sites, a key operation is the $φ_j(i)$ query, which returns the haplotype index immediately preceding $S_i$ in co-lexicographic order at site $j$. Efficient support for $k$ iterative queries $φ^1, \dots, φ^k$ is essential for haplotype matching and variation analysis. In this work, we introduce a simple and novel decomposition scheme that decomposes each haplotype row into sub-intervals, called refined segments, within which a haplotype's co-lexicographic predecessor for the sites remains unchanged. We show that refined segments satisfy two key properties: (i) each segment $[b,e]$ associated with $S_i$ overlaps with at most a constant number of segments of $S_{φ_e(i)}$, and (ii) the total number of segments is bounded by $O(\tilde{r} + h)$, where $\tilde{r}$ denotes the number of runs in the PBWT. Building on this decomposition, we present two space-time tradeoffs for supporting $k$ iterative $φ$ queries: (i) a structure using $O((\tilde{r} + h)\log n)$ bits of space that answers $k$ iterative queries in $O(\log \log_w \min(m,h) + k)$ time, where $n = m \cdot h$, and (ii) a more compact structure using $O(\tilde{r} \log h + h \log n)$ bits of space that supports queries in $O(k \log \log_w h)$ time. Prior to our work, supporting these queries required $O((\tilde{r} + h)\log n)$ bits of space and $O(k \cdot \log \log_w m)$ time. Our second tradeoff is expected to be effective in practice for modern genomic datasets, where the number $h$ of haplotypes is typically much smaller than the number $m$ of sites.

Authors: Paola Bonizzoni, Travis Gagie, Younan Gao

The Positional Burrows-Wheeler Transform (PBWT) is a fundamental data structure for the efficient representation and analysis of large-scale haplotype panels. For a panel of $h$ sequences $\{S_1, \dots, S_h\}$ over $m$ sites, a key operation is the $φ_j(i)$ query, which returns the haplotype index immediately preceding $S_i$ in co-lexicographic order at site $j$. Efficient support for $k$ iterative queries $φ^1, \dots, φ^k$ is essential for haplotype matching and variation analysis. In this work, we introduce a simple and novel decomposition scheme that decomposes each haplotype row into sub-intervals, called refined segments, within which a haplotype's co-lexicographic predecessor for the sites remains unchanged. We show that refined segments satisfy two key properties: (i) each segment $[b,e]$ associated with $S_i$ overlaps with at most a constant number of segments of $S_{φ_e(i)}$, and (ii) the total number of segments is bounded by $O(\tilde{r} + h)$, where $\tilde{r}$ denotes the number of runs in the PBWT. Building on this decomposition, we present two space-time tradeoffs for supporting $k$ iterative $φ$ queries: (i) a structure using $O((\tilde{r} + h)\log n)$ bits of space that answers $k$ iterative queries in $O(\log \log_w \min(m,h) + k)$ time, where $n = m \cdot h$, and (ii) a more compact structure using $O(\tilde{r} \log h + h \log n)$ bits of space that supports queries in $O(k \log \log_w h)$ time. Prior to our work, supporting these queries required $O((\tilde{r} + h)\log n)$ bits of space and $O(k \cdot \log \log_w m)$ time. Our second tradeoff is expected to be effective in practice for modern genomic datasets, where the number $h$ of haplotypes is typically much smaller than the number $m$ of sites.

Thursday, May 07 2026, 00:00

Nearly-Tight Bounds for Zonotope Containment and Beyond

Authors: Friedrich Eisenbrand, Thomas Rothvoss, Matteo Russo, Ruben Skorupinski

We investigate the convex-body containment problem $\max\{s >0 : s Z \subseteq Q\}$, where the outer body $Q \subseteq \mathbb R^d$ is described by a membership oracle and the inner body $Z \subseteq \mathbb R^d$ is a zonotope. Our main result is a sampling-based $O(\sqrt{d})$-approximation algorithm for this problem that almost matches the lower bound of $Ω(\sqrt{d/\log d})$ by Khot and Naor in the oracle model. Assuming zonotopes can be sparsified by a linear number of generators, which is referred to as Talagrand conjecture, our approach attains the optimal approximation factor of $Θ(\sqrt{d/\log d})$. Our second main result is a proof of Talagrand's conjecture for $Δ$-modular zonotopes whenever $Δ$ is constant. Those zonotopes are of the form $Z = \{ Wx \colon \| x\|_\infty \leq 1\}$ where the non-zero $d \times d$ sub-determinants of $W$ are between $1$ and $Δ$. This result establishes a connection between zonoid sparsification and spectral sparsification of Batson, Spielman and Srivastava. We complement these results with a universal $Ω(\sqrt{d/\log d})$ lower bound holding for all zonotopes. Finally, we consider containment problems $\max\{s >0 : s K \subseteq Q\}$, for general convex bodies $K \subseteq \mathbb R^d$. A result of Naszódi on approximating $K \subseteq \mathbb R^d$ by a polytope implies a $Θ(d/\log d)$ approximation algorithm in polynomial time. We show the tightness of this approximation factor in the oracle model via a reduction to the circumradius computation. Our lower bound holds for centrally symmetric convex sets, implying that Barvinok's optimal $O(\sqrt{d})$-approximation of a centrally symmetric convex body by a polytope with a polynomial number of vertices cannot be computed in polynomial time.

Authors: Friedrich Eisenbrand, Thomas Rothvoss, Matteo Russo, Ruben Skorupinski

We investigate the convex-body containment problem $\max\{s >0 : s Z \subseteq Q\}$, where the outer body $Q \subseteq \mathbb R^d$ is described by a membership oracle and the inner body $Z \subseteq \mathbb R^d$ is a zonotope. Our main result is a sampling-based $O(\sqrt{d})$-approximation algorithm for this problem that almost matches the lower bound of $Ω(\sqrt{d/\log d})$ by Khot and Naor in the oracle model. Assuming zonotopes can be sparsified by a linear number of generators, which is referred to as Talagrand conjecture, our approach attains the optimal approximation factor of $Θ(\sqrt{d/\log d})$. Our second main result is a proof of Talagrand's conjecture for $Δ$-modular zonotopes whenever $Δ$ is constant. Those zonotopes are of the form $Z = \{ Wx \colon \| x\|_\infty \leq 1\}$ where the non-zero $d \times d$ sub-determinants of $W$ are between $1$ and $Δ$. This result establishes a connection between zonoid sparsification and spectral sparsification of Batson, Spielman and Srivastava. We complement these results with a universal $Ω(\sqrt{d/\log d})$ lower bound holding for all zonotopes. Finally, we consider containment problems $\max\{s >0 : s K \subseteq Q\}$, for general convex bodies $K \subseteq \mathbb R^d$. A result of Naszódi on approximating $K \subseteq \mathbb R^d$ by a polytope implies a $Θ(d/\log d)$ approximation algorithm in polynomial time. We show the tightness of this approximation factor in the oracle model via a reduction to the circumradius computation. Our lower bound holds for centrally symmetric convex sets, implying that Barvinok's optimal $O(\sqrt{d})$-approximation of a centrally symmetric convex body by a polytope with a polynomial number of vertices cannot be computed in polynomial time.

Thursday, May 07 2026, 00:00

When do we know someone has died

from Computational Complexity

As the blog of record in computational complexity, we like to bring attention to those in the community who have left us. When we learn of someone in our field who has died, Bill and I will talk to each other and decide whether we should do a social media post or a full blog post, and who should write it, Bill, me, or someone else. In fact, if I call Bill, he'll often answer the phone with "who died?"

We also remember those who passed away during the year in our end-of-year post.

One challenge is how we actually know when somebody has died. Consider Michael Rabin. His death was announced on Wikipedia based on the following announcement in Haaretz, an Israeli newspaper.

♦ Haaretz Obit (Translated by Google)
That's a pretty simple obituary for a very famous computer scientist. Rabin is a common name in Israel, and there easily could have been another professor named Michael Rabin somewhere in the country. Every mention of Michael Rabin's death that I saw was just citing the Wikipedia article, nothing from Tal Rabin or some other source that cited the family.

By the time Bill put up the first Rabin post on April 22, we figured that had our Michael Rabin not died, someone would have come forward about it.

Tony Hoare is a different story, where our blog was one of the first to break the news. I heard from two separate people that they had heard from the family that he had passed away. It helped that I was in Oxford at the time, where Hoare spent much of his career.

And too often a theoretical computer scientist passes away but the news never reaches us and we don't remember them. It's always sad when someone passes, but it is a good opportunity to remember how they helped shape our field. But we need your help to know when someone has passed away. So if you know someone in our community has passed away, please let us know, and how you know, so that we can know we know.

By Lance Fortnow

As the blog of record in computational complexity, we like to bring attention to those in the community who have left us. When we learn of someone in our field who has died, Bill and I will talk to each other and decide whether we should do a social media post or a full blog post, and who should write it, Bill, me, or someone else. In fact, if I call Bill, he'll often answer the phone with "who died?"

We also remember those who passed away during the year in our end-of-year post.

One challenge is how we actually know when somebody has died. Consider Michael Rabin. His death was announced on Wikipedia based on the following announcement in Haaretz, an Israeli newspaper.

Haaretz Obit (Translated by Google)

That's a pretty simple obituary for a very famous computer scientist. Rabin is a common name in Israel, and there easily could have been another professor named Michael Rabin somewhere in the country. Every mention of Michael Rabin's death that I saw was just citing the Wikipedia article, nothing from Tal Rabin or some other source that cited the family.

By the time Bill put up the first Rabin post on April 22, we figured that had our Michael Rabin not died, someone would have come forward about it.

Tony Hoare is a different story, where our blog was one of the first to break the news. I heard from two separate people that they had heard from the family that he had passed away. It helped that I was in Oxford at the time, where Hoare spent much of his career.

And too often a theoretical computer scientist passes away but the news never reaches us and we don't remember them. It's always sad when someone passes, but it is a good opportunity to remember how they helped shape our field. But we need your help to know when someone has passed away. So if you know someone in our community has passed away, please let us know, and how you know, so that we can know we know.

By Lance Fortnow

Wednesday, May 06 2026, 13:46

Robustness and Transferability of Pix2Geomodel for Bidirectional Facies Property Translation in a Complex Reservoir

Authors: Abdulrahman Al-Fakih, Nabil Sariah, Ardiansyah Koeshidayatullah, Sherif Hanafy, SanLinn I. Kaka

Reservoir geomodeling is central to subsurface characterization, but it remains challenging because conditioning data are sparse, geological heterogeneity is strong, and conventional geostatistical workflows often struggle to capture nonlinear relationships between facies and petrophysical properties. This study evaluates the robustness and transferability of Pix2Geomodel on a different and more complex reservoir dataset with reduced vertical support. The new case includes a heterogeneous reservoir-quality classification and only 54 retained layers, providing a stricter test of whether Pix2Pix-based image-to-image translation can preserve facies-property relationships under constrained data conditions. Facies, porosity, permeability, and clay volume (VCL) were extracted from a reference reservoir model, exported as aligned two-dimensional slices, augmented using consistent geometric transformations, and assembled into paired image datasets. Six bidirectional tasks were evaluated: facies to porosity, facies to permeability, facies to VCL, porosity to facies, permeability to facies, and VCL to facies. The Pix2Pix model, consisting of a U-Net generator and PatchGAN discriminator, was evaluated using image-based metrics, visual comparison, and variogram-based spatial-continuity validation. Results show that the model preserves the dominant geological architecture and main spatial-continuity trends. Facies to porosity achieved the highest pixel accuracy and frequency-weighted intersection over union of 0.9326 and 0.8807, while VCL to facies achieved the highest mean pixel accuracy and mean intersection over union of 0.8506 and 0.7049. These findings show that Pix2Geomodel can transfer beyond its original case study as a practical framework for rapid bidirectional facies-property translation in complex reservoir modeling.

Authors: Abdulrahman Al-Fakih, Nabil Sariah, Ardiansyah Koeshidayatullah, Sherif Hanafy, SanLinn I. Kaka

Reservoir geomodeling is central to subsurface characterization, but it remains challenging because conditioning data are sparse, geological heterogeneity is strong, and conventional geostatistical workflows often struggle to capture nonlinear relationships between facies and petrophysical properties. This study evaluates the robustness and transferability of Pix2Geomodel on a different and more complex reservoir dataset with reduced vertical support. The new case includes a heterogeneous reservoir-quality classification and only 54 retained layers, providing a stricter test of whether Pix2Pix-based image-to-image translation can preserve facies-property relationships under constrained data conditions. Facies, porosity, permeability, and clay volume (VCL) were extracted from a reference reservoir model, exported as aligned two-dimensional slices, augmented using consistent geometric transformations, and assembled into paired image datasets. Six bidirectional tasks were evaluated: facies to porosity, facies to permeability, facies to VCL, porosity to facies, permeability to facies, and VCL to facies. The Pix2Pix model, consisting of a U-Net generator and PatchGAN discriminator, was evaluated using image-based metrics, visual comparison, and variogram-based spatial-continuity validation. Results show that the model preserves the dominant geological architecture and main spatial-continuity trends. Facies to porosity achieved the highest pixel accuracy and frequency-weighted intersection over union of 0.9326 and 0.8807, while VCL to facies achieved the highest mean pixel accuracy and mean intersection over union of 0.8506 and 0.7049. These findings show that Pix2Geomodel can transfer beyond its original case study as a practical framework for rapid bidirectional facies-property translation in complex reservoir modeling.

Wednesday, May 06 2026, 00:00

On the Induced Norms of Matrices and Grothendieck problems

Authors: Lan V. Truong, M. H. Duong

We study the induced matrix norm $\|\bA\|_{q \to r}$, whose exact value has been known only in a few classical cases. Determining this norm has long been regarded as difficult due to the highly non-convex nature of its variational definition. Existing works offer numerical estimates or analytic bounds but no exact formula. In this paper we present a purely analytic framework that determines $\|\bA\|_{q \to r}$ exactly for all $q, r \ge 1$ for several classes of important matrices. For these matrices, using a direct connection between the induced norms and Grothendieck problems, our results also simultaneously provide exact values for the later.

Authors: Lan V. Truong, M. H. Duong

We study the induced matrix norm $\|\bA\|_{q \to r}$, whose exact value has been known only in a few classical cases. Determining this norm has long been regarded as difficult due to the highly non-convex nature of its variational definition. Existing works offer numerical estimates or analytic bounds but no exact formula. In this paper we present a purely analytic framework that determines $\|\bA\|_{q \to r}$ exactly for all $q, r \ge 1$ for several classes of important matrices. For these matrices, using a direct connection between the induced norms and Grothendieck problems, our results also simultaneously provide exact values for the later.

Wednesday, May 06 2026, 00:00

A Critical Comment on 'Entropy Computing: A Paradigm for Optimization in Open Photonic Systems'

Authors: Ali Hamed Moosavian, Bahram Abedi Ravan

In this article, we take a close look at Entropy Quantum Computing (EQC), a computational paradigm developed by Quantum Computing Inc. (QCi), which deviates from mainstream quantum computing by embracing rather than battling environmental noise and decoherence arXiv:2407.04512 . In their words this approach purports EQC as an open quantum system that turns "entropy into super-power fuels of its computing engine". We show that some of the claims in the main article can be made more rigorous, and yet these are still not good enough to beat state of the art classical algorithms on conventional classical computers. Note that these conclusions reflect the technology's current early stage of development and are not meant to discourage its pursuit. Continued rigorous exploration is necessary to fully assess the long-term viability and potential advantages of this distinct computational approach.

Authors: Ali Hamed Moosavian, Bahram Abedi Ravan

In this article, we take a close look at Entropy Quantum Computing (EQC), a computational paradigm developed by Quantum Computing Inc. (QCi), which deviates from mainstream quantum computing by embracing rather than battling environmental noise and decoherence arXiv:2407.04512 . In their words this approach purports EQC as an open quantum system that turns "entropy into super-power fuels of its computing engine". We show that some of the claims in the main article can be made more rigorous, and yet these are still not good enough to beat state of the art classical algorithms on conventional classical computers. Note that these conclusions reflect the technology's current early stage of development and are not meant to discourage its pursuit. Continued rigorous exploration is necessary to fully assess the long-term viability and potential advantages of this distinct computational approach.

Wednesday, May 06 2026, 00:00

Optimal Union Probability Interval Is NP-Hard

Authors: Petteri Kaski, Heikki Mannila, Chandra Kanta Mohapatra

A problem dating back to Boole [Laws of Thought, Walton & Maberly,1854] is what can be computed about the probability of a finite union of events when given as input the probabilities of intersections of some of the events. The modern geometric study of the problem can be traced back to Hailperin [Amer. Math. Monthly 2 (1965) 343--359] who phrased the problem in the language of linear programming and generalized it to logical formulas of the events other than disjunction, heralding a substantial body of work in probabilistic logic [Nilsson, Artif.\ Intell.\ 28 (1986) 71--87], including the probabilistic satisfiability problem of Georgakopoulos, Kavvadis, and Papadimitriou [J.Complexity 4 (1988) 1--11], as well as fundamental connections to the geometry of metrics via cut and correlation polytopes [Deza and Laurent, Geometry of Cuts and Metrics, Springer, 1997] and to the study of marginal polytopes in graphical models of machine learning [Wainwright and Jordan, Found.\ Trends Mach.\ Learn. 1 (2008) 1--305]. This paper (i) describes the pertinent geometry of Boole's problem via coordinate projections of an elementary polytope arising essentially from Hailperin's linear program on the atoms of a Venn diagram, and (ii) shows that computing the optimal interval for the union probability is NP-hard, resolving an apparent gap in the literature highlighted by Pitowsky [Math.\ Programming 50 (1991) 395--414] and Boros et al. [Math.\ Oper.\ Res. 39 (2014) 1311--1329 and 51 (2026) 134--148].

Authors: Petteri Kaski, Heikki Mannila, Chandra Kanta Mohapatra

A problem dating back to Boole [Laws of Thought, Walton & Maberly,1854] is what can be computed about the probability of a finite union of events when given as input the probabilities of intersections of some of the events. The modern geometric study of the problem can be traced back to Hailperin [Amer. Math. Monthly 2 (1965) 343--359] who phrased the problem in the language of linear programming and generalized it to logical formulas of the events other than disjunction, heralding a substantial body of work in probabilistic logic [Nilsson, Artif.\ Intell.\ 28 (1986) 71--87], including the probabilistic satisfiability problem of Georgakopoulos, Kavvadis, and Papadimitriou [J.Complexity 4 (1988) 1--11], as well as fundamental connections to the geometry of metrics via cut and correlation polytopes [Deza and Laurent, Geometry of Cuts and Metrics, Springer, 1997] and to the study of marginal polytopes in graphical models of machine learning [Wainwright and Jordan, Found.\ Trends Mach.\ Learn. 1 (2008) 1--305]. This paper (i) describes the pertinent geometry of Boole's problem via coordinate projections of an elementary polytope arising essentially from Hailperin's linear program on the atoms of a Venn diagram, and (ii) shows that computing the optimal interval for the union probability is NP-hard, resolving an apparent gap in the literature highlighted by Pitowsky [Math.\ Programming 50 (1991) 395--414] and Boros et al. [Math.\ Oper.\ Res. 39 (2014) 1311--1329 and 51 (2026) 134--148].

Wednesday, May 06 2026, 00:00

Exponential-Size Circuit Complexity is Comeager in Symmetric Exponential Time

Authors: John M. Hitchcock

Lutz (1987) introduced resource-bounded category and showed the circuit size class SIZE($\frac{2^n}{n}$) is meager within ESPACE. Li (2024) established that the symmetric alternation class $S^E_2$ contains problems requiring circuits of size $\frac{2^n}{n}$. In this note, we extend resource-bounded category to $S^E_2$ by defining meagerness relative to single-valued $FS^P_2$ strategies in the Banach-Mazur game. We show that Li's $FS^P_2$ algorithm for the Range Avoidance problem yields a winning strategy, proving that SIZE($\frac{2^n}{n}$) is meager in $S^E_2$. Consequently, languages requiring exponential-size circuits are comeager in $S^E_2$: they are typical with respect to resource-bounded category.

Authors: John M. Hitchcock

Lutz (1987) introduced resource-bounded category and showed the circuit size class SIZE($\frac{2^n}{n}$) is meager within ESPACE. Li (2024) established that the symmetric alternation class $S^E_2$ contains problems requiring circuits of size $\frac{2^n}{n}$. In this note, we extend resource-bounded category to $S^E_2$ by defining meagerness relative to single-valued $FS^P_2$ strategies in the Banach-Mazur game. We show that Li's $FS^P_2$ algorithm for the Range Avoidance problem yields a winning strategy, proving that SIZE($\frac{2^n}{n}$) is meager in $S^E_2$. Consequently, languages requiring exponential-size circuits are comeager in $S^E_2$: they are typical with respect to resource-bounded category.

Wednesday, May 06 2026, 00:00

Computing Planar Convex Hulls with a Promise

Authors: Sepideh Aghamolaei, Kevin Buchin, Timothy M. Chan, Jacobus Conradi, Ivor Van der Hoog, Vahideh Keikha, Jeff M. Phillips, Benjamin Raichel

Computing the convex hull of a planar $n$-point set $P$ is one of the most fundamental problems in computational geometry. It has an $Ω(n \log n)$ lower bound in the algebraic computation tree model, and many convex hull algorithms match this bound. Classical results show that, under special input assumptions, sub-$O(n \log n)$ algorithms are possible. For instance, when the points are given in lexicographic or angular order, the convex hull can be computed in linear time. Even under the weaker assumption that the sequence of points corresponds to the ordered vertices of a simple polygonal chain, linear-time algorithms exist. This naturally raises the question: can the convex hull of a point set be computed in sub-$O(n \log n)$ time under weaker input assumptions? We answer this positively. Under the promise that the input sequence contains the convex hull as a subsequence, we give a deterministic $O(n \sqrt{\log n})$-time algorithm to compute the convex hull of $P$. With randomisation, we achieve expected running time $O(n \log^{\varepsilon} n)$ for any constant $\varepsilon > 0$. We find this surprising, as points not on the convex hull may behave adversarially toward our convex hull construction algorithm. Yet the promise that \emph{only} the hull points are sorted suffices for $o(n \log n)$-time algorithms. Finally, we show that this promise is tight: if it is even slightly broken, i.e., allowing just one hull point to appear out of order, we prove an adversarial $Ω(n \log n)$-time lower bound. Consequently, the promise cannot be verified with fewer than $Ω(n \log n)$ comparisons. This also negatively resolves an open problem of Löffler and Raichel, who conjectured sub-$O(n \log n)$-time algorithms for computing the convex hull of a supersequence containing the hull as a subsequence.

Authors: Sepideh Aghamolaei, Kevin Buchin, Timothy M. Chan, Jacobus Conradi, Ivor Van der Hoog, Vahideh Keikha, Jeff M. Phillips, Benjamin Raichel

Computing the convex hull of a planar $n$-point set $P$ is one of the most fundamental problems in computational geometry. It has an $Ω(n \log n)$ lower bound in the algebraic computation tree model, and many convex hull algorithms match this bound. Classical results show that, under special input assumptions, sub-$O(n \log n)$ algorithms are possible. For instance, when the points are given in lexicographic or angular order, the convex hull can be computed in linear time. Even under the weaker assumption that the sequence of points corresponds to the ordered vertices of a simple polygonal chain, linear-time algorithms exist. This naturally raises the question: can the convex hull of a point set be computed in sub-$O(n \log n)$ time under weaker input assumptions? We answer this positively. Under the promise that the input sequence contains the convex hull as a subsequence, we give a deterministic $O(n \sqrt{\log n})$-time algorithm to compute the convex hull of $P$. With randomisation, we achieve expected running time $O(n \log^{\varepsilon} n)$ for any constant $\varepsilon > 0$. We find this surprising, as points not on the convex hull may behave adversarially toward our convex hull construction algorithm. Yet the promise that \emph{only} the hull points are sorted suffices for $o(n \log n)$-time algorithms. Finally, we show that this promise is tight: if it is even slightly broken, i.e., allowing just one hull point to appear out of order, we prove an adversarial $Ω(n \log n)$-time lower bound. Consequently, the promise cannot be verified with fewer than $Ω(n \log n)$ comparisons. This also negatively resolves an open problem of Löffler and Raichel, who conjectured sub-$O(n \log n)$-time algorithms for computing the convex hull of a supersequence containing the hull as a subsequence.

Wednesday, May 06 2026, 00:00

Optimally Covering Large Triangles with Homothetic Unit Triangles

Authors: John M. Boyer

We answer an open problem in the \emph{American Mathematical Monthly} about covering large triangles. Given a triangle $T$ of any triangular shape with a selected side length between $n \in \mathbb{N}$ and $n+1$, Baek and Lee proved that $T$ could not be covered with $n^2+1$ homothetic unit triangles (with the selected side of length 1). Letting $T_{n+d}$ denote a triangle with selected side length $n + d$ with $d \in (0, 1)$, Baek and Lee extended their proof to establish upper bounds for $d$ above which a $T_{n+d}$ cannot be covered with $n^2+2$ or $n^2+3$ homothetic unit triangles. Then, they showed that these bounds are tight based on analyses of a method by Conway and Soifer for the $n^2+2$ case and their own method for the $n^2+3$ case. Baek and Lee stated as an open problem the need to find tight upper bounds for the $n^2 + k$ cases for $4 \le k \le 2n$. We extend the Baek and Lee proof to establish upper bounds for those higher cases, and we show the upper bounds are tight by presenting two new triangle covering methods for the odd and even cases of $k$ that meet the upper bounds, as well as an optimal consolidated method that uses whichever of the two will cover a given $T_{n+d}$ with the fewest homothetic unit triangles.

Authors: John M. Boyer

We answer an open problem in the \emph{American Mathematical Monthly} about covering large triangles. Given a triangle $T$ of any triangular shape with a selected side length between $n \in \mathbb{N}$ and $n+1$, Baek and Lee proved that $T$ could not be covered with $n^2+1$ homothetic unit triangles (with the selected side of length 1). Letting $T_{n+d}$ denote a triangle with selected side length $n + d$ with $d \in (0, 1)$, Baek and Lee extended their proof to establish upper bounds for $d$ above which a $T_{n+d}$ cannot be covered with $n^2+2$ or $n^2+3$ homothetic unit triangles. Then, they showed that these bounds are tight based on analyses of a method by Conway and Soifer for the $n^2+2$ case and their own method for the $n^2+3$ case. Baek and Lee stated as an open problem the need to find tight upper bounds for the $n^2 + k$ cases for $4 \le k \le 2n$. We extend the Baek and Lee proof to establish upper bounds for those higher cases, and we show the upper bounds are tight by presenting two new triangle covering methods for the odd and even cases of $k$ that meet the upper bounds, as well as an optimal consolidated method that uses whichever of the two will cover a given $T_{n+d}$ with the fewest homothetic unit triangles.

Wednesday, May 06 2026, 00:00

An $\widetilde{O} (n^{3/7})$ Round Parallel Algorithm for Matroid Bases

Authors: Sanjeev Khanna, Aaron Putterman, Junkai Song

We study the parallel (adaptive) complexity of the classic problem of finding a basis in an $n$-element matroid, given access via an \emph{independence oracle}. In this model, the algorithm may submit polynomially many independence queries in each round, and the central question is: how many rounds are necessary and sufficient to find a basis? Karp, Upfal, and Wigderson (FOCS~1985, JCSS~1988; hereafter KUW) initiated this study, showing that $O(\sqrt{n})$ adaptive rounds suffice for any matroid, and that $\widetildeΩ(n^{1/3})$ rounds are necessary even for partition matroids. This left a substantial gap that persisted for nearly four decades, until Khanna, Putterman, and Song (FOCS~2025; hereafter KPS) achieved $\widetilde O(n^{7/15})$ rounds, the first improvement since~KUW. In this work, we make another conceptual advance beyond KPS, giving a new algorithm that finds a matroid basis in $\widetilde O(n^{3/7})$ rounds. We develop a structural and algorithmic framework that brings a new lens to the analysis of random circuits, moving from reasoning about individual elements to understanding how dependencies span multiple elements simultaneously.

Authors: Sanjeev Khanna, Aaron Putterman, Junkai Song

We study the parallel (adaptive) complexity of the classic problem of finding a basis in an $n$-element matroid, given access via an \emph{independence oracle}. In this model, the algorithm may submit polynomially many independence queries in each round, and the central question is: how many rounds are necessary and sufficient to find a basis? Karp, Upfal, and Wigderson (FOCS~1985, JCSS~1988; hereafter KUW) initiated this study, showing that $O(\sqrt{n})$ adaptive rounds suffice for any matroid, and that $\widetildeΩ(n^{1/3})$ rounds are necessary even for partition matroids. This left a substantial gap that persisted for nearly four decades, until Khanna, Putterman, and Song (FOCS~2025; hereafter KPS) achieved $\widetilde O(n^{7/15})$ rounds, the first improvement since~KUW. In this work, we make another conceptual advance beyond KPS, giving a new algorithm that finds a matroid basis in $\widetilde O(n^{3/7})$ rounds. We develop a structural and algorithmic framework that brings a new lens to the analysis of random circuits, moving from reasoning about individual elements to understanding how dependencies span multiple elements simultaneously.

Wednesday, May 06 2026, 00:00

Optimal Hardness of Online Algorithms for Large Common Induced Subgraphs

Authors: David Gamarnik, Miklós Z. Rácz, Gabe Schoenbach

We study the problem of efficiently finding large common induced subgraphs of two independent Erdős--Rényi random graphs $G_1, G_2 \sim \mathbb{G}(n,1/2)$. Recently, Chatterjee and Diaconis showed that the largest common induced subgraph of $G_1$ and $G_2$ has size $(4-o(1))\log_2 n$ with high probability. We first show that a simple greedy online algorithm finds a common induced subgraph of $G_1$ and $G_2$ of size $(2-o(1)) \log_2 n$ with high probability. Our main result shows that no online algorithm can find a common induced subgraph of $G_1$ and $G_2$ of size at least $(2+\varepsilon) \log_2 n$ with probability bounded away from $0$ as $n \to \infty$. Together, these results provide evidence that this problem exhibits a computation-to-optimization gap. To prove the impossibility result, we show that the solution space of the problem exhibits a version of the (multi) overlap gap property (OGP), and utilize an interpolation argument recently developed by Gamarnik, Kizildağ, and Warnke that connects OGP and online algorithms.

Authors: David Gamarnik, Miklós Z. Rácz, Gabe Schoenbach

We study the problem of efficiently finding large common induced subgraphs of two independent Erdős--Rényi random graphs $G_1, G_2 \sim \mathbb{G}(n,1/2)$. Recently, Chatterjee and Diaconis showed that the largest common induced subgraph of $G_1$ and $G_2$ has size $(4-o(1))\log_2 n$ with high probability. We first show that a simple greedy online algorithm finds a common induced subgraph of $G_1$ and $G_2$ of size $(2-o(1)) \log_2 n$ with high probability. Our main result shows that no online algorithm can find a common induced subgraph of $G_1$ and $G_2$ of size at least $(2+\varepsilon) \log_2 n$ with probability bounded away from $0$ as $n \to \infty$. Together, these results provide evidence that this problem exhibits a computation-to-optimization gap. To prove the impossibility result, we show that the solution space of the problem exhibits a version of the (multi) overlap gap property (OGP), and utilize an interpolation argument recently developed by Gamarnik, Kizildağ, and Warnke that connects OGP and online algorithms.

Wednesday, May 06 2026, 00:00

The Parameterized Complexity of Scheduling with Precedence Delays: Shuffle Product and Directed Bandwidth

Authors: Hans L. Bodlaender, Maher Mallem

In this paper, we study the parameterized complexity of several variants of scheduling with precedence constraints between jobs. Namely, we consider the single machine setting with delay values on top of the precedence constraints. Such scheduling problems are related to several decades-old problems with open parameterized complexity status, notably Shuffle Product and Directed Bandwidth. We obtain XNLP-completeness results for both problems, and derive implications to scheduling with minimum (resp. maximum) delays parameterized by the width of the directed acyclic graph giving the precedence constraints, and/or by the maximum delay value in the input. Regarding Directed Bandwidth, we also settle the case of trees by showing XNLP-completeness parameterized by the target value. Beyond these results, we believe that Shuffle Product is an unusual and promising addition to the list of XNLP-complete problems.

Authors: Hans L. Bodlaender, Maher Mallem

In this paper, we study the parameterized complexity of several variants of scheduling with precedence constraints between jobs. Namely, we consider the single machine setting with delay values on top of the precedence constraints. Such scheduling problems are related to several decades-old problems with open parameterized complexity status, notably Shuffle Product and Directed Bandwidth. We obtain XNLP-completeness results for both problems, and derive implications to scheduling with minimum (resp. maximum) delays parameterized by the width of the directed acyclic graph giving the precedence constraints, and/or by the maximum delay value in the input. Regarding Directed Bandwidth, we also settle the case of trees by showing XNLP-completeness parameterized by the target value. Beyond these results, we believe that Shuffle Product is an unusual and promising addition to the list of XNLP-complete problems.

Wednesday, May 06 2026, 00:00

Quantum Multi-Level Estimation of Functionals of Discrete Distributions

Authors: Kean Chen, Minbo Gao, Tongyang Li, Qisheng Wang, Xinzhao Wang

We propose a quantum multi-level estimation framework for a functional $\sum_{i=1}^n f(p_i)$ of a discrete distribution $(p_i)_{i=1}^n$. We partition the values $p_i$ into logarithmically many intervals whose length decays exponentially. For each interval, we perform non-destructive singular value discrimination to isolate the relevant $p_i$, enabling adaptive estimation of the partial sum over this interval. Unlike previous variable-time approaches, our method avoids high control overhead and requires only constant extra ancilla qubits. As an application, we present efficient quantum estimators for the $q$-Tsallis entropy of discrete distributions. Specifically: (i) For $q > 1$, we obtain a near-optimal quantum algorithm with query complexity $\tildeΘ(1/\varepsilon^{\max\{1/(2(q-1)), 1\}})$, improving the prior best $O(1/\varepsilon^{1+1/(q-1)})$ due to Liu and Wang (SODA 2025; IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 2026). (ii) For $0 < q < 1$, we obtain a quantum algorithm with query complexity $\tilde{O}(n^{1/q-1/2}/\varepsilon^{1/q})$, exhibiting a quantum speedup over the near-optimal classical estimators due to Jiao, Venkat, Han, and Weissman (IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 2017). Our results achieve, to our knowledge, the first near-optimal quantum estimators for parameterized $q$-entropy for non-integer $q$.

Authors: Kean Chen, Minbo Gao, Tongyang Li, Qisheng Wang, Xinzhao Wang

We propose a quantum multi-level estimation framework for a functional $\sum_{i=1}^n f(p_i)$ of a discrete distribution $(p_i)_{i=1}^n$. We partition the values $p_i$ into logarithmically many intervals whose length decays exponentially. For each interval, we perform non-destructive singular value discrimination to isolate the relevant $p_i$, enabling adaptive estimation of the partial sum over this interval. Unlike previous variable-time approaches, our method avoids high control overhead and requires only constant extra ancilla qubits. As an application, we present efficient quantum estimators for the $q$-Tsallis entropy of discrete distributions. Specifically: (i) For $q > 1$, we obtain a near-optimal quantum algorithm with query complexity $\tildeΘ(1/\varepsilon^{\max\{1/(2(q-1)), 1\}})$, improving the prior best $O(1/\varepsilon^{1+1/(q-1)})$ due to Liu and Wang (SODA 2025; IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 2026). (ii) For $0 < q < 1$, we obtain a quantum algorithm with query complexity $\tilde{O}(n^{1/q-1/2}/\varepsilon^{1/q})$, exhibiting a quantum speedup over the near-optimal classical estimators due to Jiao, Venkat, Han, and Weissman (IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 2017). Our results achieve, to our knowledge, the first near-optimal quantum estimators for parameterized $q$-entropy for non-integer $q$.

Wednesday, May 06 2026, 00:00

Exact and Approximate Algorithms for Polytree Learning

Authors: Juha Harviainen, Frank Sommer, Manuel Sorge

Polytrees are a subclass of Bayesian networks that seek to capture the conditional dependencies between a set of $n$ variables as a directed forest and are motivated by their more efficient inference and improved interpretability. Since the problem of learning the best polytree is NP-hard, we study which restrictions make it more tractable by considering for example in-degree bounds, properties of score functions measuring the quality of a polytree, and approximation algorithms. We devise an algorithm that finds the optimal polytree in time $O((2+ε)^n)$ for arbitrarily small $ε> 0$ and any constant in-degree bound $k$, improving over the fastest previously known algorithm of time complexity $O(3^n)$. We further give polynomial-time algorithms for finding a polytree whose score is within a factor of $k$ from the optimal one for arbitrary scores and a factor of $2$ for additive ones. Many of the results are complemented by (nearly) tight lower bounds for either the time complexity or the approximation factors.

Authors: Juha Harviainen, Frank Sommer, Manuel Sorge

Polytrees are a subclass of Bayesian networks that seek to capture the conditional dependencies between a set of $n$ variables as a directed forest and are motivated by their more efficient inference and improved interpretability. Since the problem of learning the best polytree is NP-hard, we study which restrictions make it more tractable by considering for example in-degree bounds, properties of score functions measuring the quality of a polytree, and approximation algorithms. We devise an algorithm that finds the optimal polytree in time $O((2+ε)^n)$ for arbitrarily small $ε> 0$ and any constant in-degree bound $k$, improving over the fastest previously known algorithm of time complexity $O(3^n)$. We further give polynomial-time algorithms for finding a polytree whose score is within a factor of $k$ from the optimal one for arbitrary scores and a factor of $2$ for additive ones. Many of the results are complemented by (nearly) tight lower bounds for either the time complexity or the approximation factors.

Wednesday, May 06 2026, 00:00

On Solving Problems of Substantially Super-linear Complexity in $N^{o(1)}$ Rounds in the MPC Model

Authors: Andrzej Lingas

We study the possibility of designing $N^{o(1)}$-round protocols for problems of substantially super-linear polynomial-time (sequential) complexity in the model of Massively Parallel Computation, where $N$ is the input size. We show that if the machines are not equipped with relatively large local memory and their number does not exceed $N$, then the exponent of the average time complexity of the local computation performed by a machine in a round (in terms of local memory size) in such protocols must be larger than the exponent of the time complexity of the given problem.

Authors: Andrzej Lingas

We study the possibility of designing $N^{o(1)}$-round protocols for problems of substantially super-linear polynomial-time (sequential) complexity in the model of Massively Parallel Computation, where $N$ is the input size. We show that if the machines are not equipped with relatively large local memory and their number does not exceed $N$, then the exponent of the average time complexity of the local computation performed by a machine in a round (in terms of local memory size) in such protocols must be larger than the exponent of the time complexity of the given problem.

Wednesday, May 06 2026, 00:00

Visibility Queries in Simple Polygons